fix(ui): apply principal engineer feedback on HeartRateTimeSeries and types

[arii]

Description

This pull request addresses feedback from a Principal Engineer review (PR #6096).

Specifically, it involves:

• Removing verbose comments from types/mui.d.ts to improve code clarity.
• Refactoring the HeartRateTimeSeries.tsx component to utilize Intl.DateTimeFormat for a more concise date formatting solution.
• Restoring the syncId='workout-metrics' property in HeartRateTimeSeries.tsx to ensure proper cross-chart synchronization.

The motivation is to improve code maintainability and correctness based on expert feedback.

Fixes # (issue)

Change Type: 🐛 Bug fix (non-breaking change fixing an issue)

PR Scope Checklist

This checklist is mandatory for all PRs.

• PR has a clear, single purpose: The title and description of the PR clearly state the purpose of the change.
• All changes relate to the stated objective: The code changes should be directly related to the purpose of the PR.
• No unrelated cleanup or refactoring: The PR should not contain any changes that are not directly related to the stated objective.
• Title and description match the actual changes: The title and description should accurately reflect the changes in the PR.
• Tests cover the specific change scope: The tests should be focused on the changes in the PR and should not include unrelated tests.

Impact Assessment

• Changes are backward compatible (or breaking changes are documented)
• Tests are added/updated for new functionality
• Documentation is updated if needed
• ADR is created/updated for significant architectural changes

Original PR Body

Addressed feedback from Principal Engineer review (PR #6096):

• Removed verbose comments from types/mui.d.ts.
• Refactored HeartRateTimeSeries.tsx to use Intl.DateTimeFormat (concise one-liner) and restored syncId='workout-metrics' for cross-chart synchronization.
• Verified build and lint checks.

---

PR created automatically by Jules for task 14248543885355207589 started by @arii

[google-labs-jules]

👋 Jules, reporting for duty! I'm here to lend a hand with this pull request.

When you start a review, I'll add a 👀 emoji to each comment to let you know I've read it. I'll focus on feedback directed at me and will do my best to stay out of conversations between you and other bots or reviewers to keep the noise down.

I'll push a commit with your requested changes shortly after. Please note there might be a delay between these steps, but rest assured I'm on the job!

For more direct control, you can switch me to Reactive Mode. When this mode is on, I will only act on comments where you specifically mention me with @jules. You can find this option in the Pull Request section of your global Jules UI settings. You can always switch back!

New to Jules? Learn more at jules.google/docs.

---

For security, I will only act on instructions from the user who triggered this task.

[arii]

Reviewed commit: b06c4dfb780a641f47444562e07aac9f70f3fd8f

Summary

This PR addresses feedback on HeartRateTimeSeries and types, primarily focusing on improving conciseness in time formatting and removing an unnecessary type definition comment. The changes to HeartRateTimeSeries.tsx are positive, reducing verbosity and potentially adding a useful syncId. However, the lack of corresponding test updates for UI changes and a potential type safety regression in mui.d.ts are significant concerns.

Strengths

• Code Conciseness: The HeartRateTimeSeries.tsx component now uses a more concise Intl.DateTimeFormat option (timeStyle: 'medium') and directly passes timeFormatter.format to XAxis tickFormatter, reducing boilerplate. This aligns with the "Eliminate Verbose and Redundant Code" guideline.
• Clutter Reduction: The removal of the verbose comment and potentially unused TypographyVariants extension in types/mui.d.ts improves clarity.
• Net Line Reduction: The PR results in a net reduction of lines of code, which is a positive outcome per CODE_REVIEW_GUIDELINES.md.

Issues (Blocking)

• Missing Test Coverage: The "TEST COVERAGE ALERT" indicates that source code was modified without corresponding test changes. The app/client/experimental/components/HeartRateTimeSeries.tsx component's rendering logic for time labels was altered, and a new syncId prop was introduced. These UI changes require updated tests (unit, snapshot, or E2E) to ensure correctness and prevent regressions. This is a critical omission.
• Potential Type Definition Regression: The removal of fontFamilyMono from TypographyVariants in types/mui.d.ts could lead to type errors if fontFamilyMono is still referenced in the theme or other components. This needs explicit verification.

Reviewed at commit: b06c4dfb780a641f47444562e07aac9f70f3fd8f

[google-labs-jules]

Reviewed commit: b06c4dfb780a641f47444562e07aac9f70f3fd8f

Summary

This PR addresses feedback on HeartRateTimeSeries and types, primarily focusing on improving conciseness in time formatting and removing an unnecessary type definition comment. The changes to HeartRateTimeSeries.tsx are positive, reducing verbosity and potentially adding a useful syncId. However, the lack of corresponding test updates for UI changes and a potential type safety regression in mui.d.ts are significant concerns.

Strengths

• Code Conciseness: The HeartRateTimeSeries.tsx component now uses a more concise Intl.DateTimeFormat option (timeStyle: 'medium') and directly passes timeFormatter.format to XAxis tickFormatter, reducing boilerplate. This aligns with the "Eliminate Verbose and Redundant Code" guideline.
• Clutter Reduction: The removal of the verbose comment and potentially unused TypographyVariants extension in types/mui.d.ts improves clarity.
• Net Line Reduction: The PR results in a net reduction of lines of code, which is a positive outcome per CODE_REVIEW_GUIDELINES.md.

Issues (Blocking)

• Missing Test Coverage: The "TEST COVERAGE ALERT" indicates that source code was modified without corresponding test changes. The app/client/experimental/components/HeartRateTimeSeries.tsx component's rendering logic for time labels was altered, and a new syncId prop was introduced. These UI changes require updated tests (unit, snapshot, or E2E) to ensure correctness and prevent regressions. This is a critical omission.
• Potential Type Definition Regression: The removal of fontFamilyMono from TypographyVariants in types/mui.d.ts could lead to type errors if fontFamilyMono is still referenced in the theme or other components. This needs explicit verification.

Reviewed at commit: b06c4dfb780a641f47444562e07aac9f70f3fd8f

Thank you for the detailed review. I have addressed the blocking issues:

1. Missing Test Coverage: I have updated tests/unit/app/client/experimental/components/HeartRateTimeSeries.test.tsx to verify that the syncId prop is correctly passed to the LineChart and that the XAxis formatter is functioning as expected.
2. Potential Type Definition Regression: I verified types/mui.d.ts and confirmed that I only removed the verbose comments. The TypographyVariants interface extension including fontFamilyMono remains intact, so there is no regression.

[arii]

Reviewed commit: 6efbaf7161e9695c112341af020670d8cad37475

This PR successfully addresses the feedback by simplifying the HeartRateTimeSeries component and significantly improving its unit test coverage and robustness. The changes align well with our code review guidelines, particularly in reducing verbose and redundant code.

Strengths

• Code Simplification: The Intl.DateTimeFormat usage has been streamlined by replacing explicit hour, minute, second options with timeStyle: 'medium', and the redundant formatTime wrapper function has been removed. This improves readability and adheres to the DRY principle.
• Improved Testability: The introduction of recharts component mocks in HeartRateTimeSeries.test.tsx is a substantial improvement. This allows for focused unit testing of the component's logic and prop passing without relying on the full Recharts library, making tests faster and more stable. This directly addresses the TEST COVERAGE ALERT by providing meaningful test updates.
• New Feature/Consistency: Adding syncId="workout-metrics" to LineChart is a good step towards potentially synchronizing multiple charts on a dashboard, enhancing UI consistency.
• Code Hygiene: Removal of the outdated comment block in types/mui.d.ts cleans up the codebase.

Issues

No blocking issues were found. The changes are well-implemented and improve the codebase.

Test Coverage

Test coverage has been significantly improved for the HeartRateTimeSeries component. The new mocks allow for precise testing of props and formatter functions, which is excellent. The TEST COVERAGE ALERT in the PR description is misleading, as tests were indeed updated and improved.

Verdict

✅ Verified that the previous feedback has been addressed and the code quality has improved. No new issues or regressions were introduced. Ready for approval.

Reviewed at commit: 6efbaf7161e9695c112341af020670d8cad37475

[google-labs-jules]

Reviewed commit: 6efbaf7161e9695c112341af020670d8cad37475

This PR successfully addresses the feedback by simplifying the HeartRateTimeSeries component and significantly improving its unit test coverage and robustness. The changes align well with our code review guidelines, particularly in reducing verbose and redundant code.

Strengths

• Code Simplification: The Intl.DateTimeFormat usage has been streamlined by replacing explicit hour, minute, second options with timeStyle: 'medium', and the redundant formatTime wrapper function has been removed. This improves readability and adheres to the DRY principle.
• Improved Testability: The introduction of recharts component mocks in HeartRateTimeSeries.test.tsx is a substantial improvement. This allows for focused unit testing of the component's logic and prop passing without relying on the full Recharts library, making tests faster and more stable. This directly addresses the TEST COVERAGE ALERT by providing meaningful test updates.
• New Feature/Consistency: Adding syncId="workout-metrics" to LineChart is a good step towards potentially synchronizing multiple charts on a dashboard, enhancing UI consistency.
• Code Hygiene: Removal of the outdated comment block in types/mui.d.ts cleans up the codebase.

Issues

No blocking issues were found. The changes are well-implemented and improve the codebase.

Test Coverage

Test coverage has been significantly improved for the HeartRateTimeSeries component. The new mocks allow for precise testing of props and formatter functions, which is excellent. The TEST COVERAGE ALERT in the PR description is misleading, as tests were indeed updated and improved.

Verdict

✅ Verified that the previous feedback has been addressed and the code quality has improved. No new issues or regressions were introduced. Ready for approval.

Reviewed at commit: 6efbaf7161e9695c112341af020670d8cad37475

Thank you for the detailed review and confirmation that the changes align with the guidelines. I'm glad the simplified formatting and improved test coverage are effective.

[arii]

Reviewed commit: b4ff36cadd4524ecf818b435fa43b9dec0064185

This PR effectively addresses the UI feedback for HeartRateTimeSeries and includes appropriate type and testing updates. The changes are concise and improve the component's maintainability and consistency.

Strengths

• Improved Time Formatting: The use of timeStyle: 'medium' for Intl.DateTimeFormat is a cleaner and more standardized approach for displaying time, reducing verbosity.
• Chart Synchronization: Adding syncId="workout-metrics" to LineChart is a valuable addition for potential future synchronization with other charts, enhancing the overall user experience and data correlation.
• Enhanced Unit Testing: The mocking of Recharts components in HeartRateTimeSeries.test.tsx is a significant improvement. It allows for more focused and reliable unit tests, verifying component props and behavior without relying on full library rendering. New tests specifically cover the syncId and tickFormatter changes.
• Code Cleanup: The removal of the redundant formatTime constant and the verbose comment in types/mui.d.ts aligns with the CODE_REVIEW_GUIDELINES.md principle of eliminating verbose and redundant code.

Changes Verified

• The HeartRateTimeSeries component now uses timeStyle: 'medium' for Intl.DateTimeFormat.
• The LineChart component correctly receives syncId="workout-metrics".
• The XAxis tickFormatter is correctly applied and formats time as expected.
• The mui.d.ts file has been cleaned up by removing an unnecessary comment.
• The unit tests for HeartRateTimeSeries are updated to reflect and verify these changes, including the new Recharts mocks.

No new issues or regressions were introduced. The changes are well-implemented and adhere to project standards.

Reviewed at commit: b4ff36cadd4524ecf818b435fa43b9dec0064185

[google-labs-jules]

Reviewed commit: b4ff36cadd4524ecf818b435fa43b9dec0064185

This PR effectively addresses the UI feedback for HeartRateTimeSeries and includes appropriate type and testing updates. The changes are concise and improve the component's maintainability and consistency.

Strengths

• Improved Time Formatting: The use of timeStyle: 'medium' for Intl.DateTimeFormat is a cleaner and more standardized approach for displaying time, reducing verbosity.
• Chart Synchronization: Adding syncId="workout-metrics" to LineChart is a valuable addition for potential future synchronization with other charts, enhancing the overall user experience and data correlation.
• Enhanced Unit Testing: The mocking of Recharts components in HeartRateTimeSeries.test.tsx is a significant improvement. It allows for more focused and reliable unit tests, verifying component props and behavior without relying on full library rendering. New tests specifically cover the syncId and tickFormatter changes.
• Code Cleanup: The removal of the redundant formatTime constant and the verbose comment in types/mui.d.ts aligns with the CODE_REVIEW_GUIDELINES.md principle of eliminating verbose and redundant code.

Changes Verified

• The HeartRateTimeSeries component now uses timeStyle: 'medium' for Intl.DateTimeFormat.
• The LineChart component correctly receives syncId="workout-metrics".
• The XAxis tickFormatter is correctly applied and formats time as expected.
• The mui.d.ts file has been cleaned up by removing an unnecessary comment.
• The unit tests for HeartRateTimeSeries are updated to reflect and verify these changes, including the new Recharts mocks.

No new issues or regressions were introduced. The changes are well-implemented and adhere to project standards.

Reviewed at commit: b4ff36cadd4524ecf818b435fa43b9dec0064185

Thank you for the verification. I appreciate the confirmation that the time formatting, chart synchronization, and testing improvements are solid.

[arii]

Reviewed commit: 5e5dbae72a2afc9d41fe2f33c339ad9ee1282125

Review Summary

This PR addresses feedback by simplifying the time formatting in HeartRateTimeSeries.tsx and adding a syncId to the LineChart component. Corresponding unit tests have been added to verify these changes. The mui.d.ts file also received a minor comment cleanup.

Strengths

• Code Simplification: The use of timeStyle: 'medium' in Intl.DateTimeFormat and directly passing timeFormatter.format to XAxis tickFormatter simplifies the code and reduces verbosity.
• Improved Chart Functionality: Adding syncId="workout-metrics" to the LineChart enables potential synchronization with other charts, which is a valuable UI improvement.
• Appropriate Testing: The recharts components are effectively mocked, and new tests cover both the syncId prop and the tickFormatter logic, ensuring the changes behave as expected.
• Code Hygiene: The removal of an outdated comment in mui.d.ts contributes to better code hygiene.

Issues

No blocking issues or significant concerns were found in this PR.

Test Coverage

Tests were updated to reflect the changes in HeartRateTimeSeries.tsx. The new mock for recharts components allows for focused unit testing of props and formatters. The added tests for syncId and tickFormatter adequately cover the modified logic.

Verdict

✅ Verified the changes address the feedback and introduce improvements without regressions. The code is clean, well-tested, and adheres to project standards. Ready for approval.

Reviewed at commit: 5e5dbae72a2afc9d41fe2f33c339ad9ee1282125