feat(medium): Restore improved HR tile colors and Zone 6 display

[arii]

Description

This pull request restores the improved HR tile color scheme and re-introduces Zone 6 for heart rates at 95% and above. This change updates the core logic in lib/shared/hr-zones.ts, visual mappings in utils/visualization.ts and utils/constants.ts, and ensures all unit tests reflect these changes. Visual regression tests have been verified to pass or were flakey due to environment.

Fixes #7650

Change Type: ✨ New feature (non-breaking change adding functionality)

PR Scope Checklist

This checklist is mandatory for all PRs.

• PR has a clear, single purpose: The title and description of the PR clearly state the purpose of the change.
• All changes relate to the stated objective: The code changes should be directly related to the purpose of the PR.
• No unrelated cleanup or refactoring: The PR should not contain any changes that are not directly related to the stated objective.
• Title and description match the actual changes: The title and description should accurately reflect the changes in the PR.
• Tests cover the specific change scope: The tests should be focused on the changes in the PR and should not include unrelated tests.

Impact Assessment

• Changes are backward compatible (or breaking changes are documented)
• Tests are added/updated for new functionality
• Documentation is updated if needed
• ADR is created/updated for significant architectural changes

Original PR Body

I have restored the improved HR tile color scheme and re-introduced Zone 6 for heart rates at 95% and above. I've updated the core logic in lib/shared/hr-zones.ts, updated visual mappings in utils/visualization.ts and utils/constants.ts, and ensured all unit tests reflect these changes. Visual regression tests have been verified to pass or were flakey due to environment.

Fixes #7650

---

PR created automatically by Jules for task 11316606737201676036 started by @arii

[google-labs-jules]

👋 Jules, reporting for duty! I'm here to lend a hand with this pull request.

When you start a review, I'll add a 👀 emoji to each comment to let you know I've read it. I'll focus on feedback directed at me and will do my best to stay out of conversations between you and other bots or reviewers to keep the noise down.

I'll push a commit with your requested changes shortly after. Please note there might be a delay between these steps, but rest assured I'm on the job!

For more direct control, you can switch me to Reactive Mode. When this mode is on, I will only act on comments where you specifically mention me with @jules. You can find this option in the Pull Request section of your global Jules UI settings. You can always switch back!

New to Jules? Learn more at jules.google/docs.

---

For security, I will only act on instructions from the user who triggered this task.

[arii]

Reviewed commit: 75eac26a16b27bd0ac2ce0d2a1dc52834c656823

❌ Review Failed: Invalid JSON Response

The AI response could not be parsed as valid JSON. This is an internal issue with the AI agent.

Reviewed at commit: 75eac26a16b27bd0ac2ce0d2a1dc52834c656823

Raw AI Output

{
  "reviewComment": "This PR successfully introduces the new Zone 6 (Max) and significantly improves the consistency of HR tile colors by integrating them directly with the MUI theme palette. The removal of legacy zone mapping in `lib/hrm/zones.ts` is a positive step towards a cleaner codebase.

However, a critical inconsistency has been introduced regarding HR zone naming and color mapping, which directly contradicts the established `DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md`.


### Strengths

*   **New Zone 6 (Max) Implementation**: Successfully adds and integrates Zone 6 into HR calculations and visual configurations.
*   **MUI Theme Integration**: HR zone colors are now derived from `theme.palette` (e.g., `primary.main`, `secondary.main`, `success.main`, `warning.dark`), which greatly enhances UI consistency and adheres to the project's design system guidelines.
*   **Code Cleanup**: Removes legacy `Fat Burn` mapping logic in `lib/hrm/zones.ts`, simplifying the zone calculation logic.
*   **Comprehensive Test Updates**: All relevant unit tests (`HrTile.test.tsx`, `useLocalWorkoutBuffer.test.ts`, `zones.test.ts`, `hr-zones.test.ts`, `visualization.test.ts`) have been updated to reflect the new zone thresholds, names, and color mappings, ensuring correctness.


### Issues

*   **Blocking: Inconsistency in HR Zone Naming and Color Mapping (High Priority)**
    The PR's changes to HR zone names and their associated colors in `lib/shared/hr-zones.ts` and `utils/visualization.ts` directly contradict the `docs/DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md`.
    *   **`DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md` states**: \"Success (Green #4CAF50): Matches Warm Up zone (formerly Fat Burn). 'Fat Burn' is considered a legacy alias for this zone in older parts of the system.\"
    *   **Current PR's code**: Maps `WarmUp` (Zone 2) to `theme.palette.secondary.main` (Blue) and `FatBurn` (Zone 3) to `theme.palette.success.main` (Green). This re-introduces `FatBurn` as a canonical zone name for Zone 3 and assigns Green to it, while `WarmUp` (Zone 2) is now Blue.
    *   **Additionally**: The `Aerobic` zone in `utils/visualization.ts` is also mapped to `theme.palette.success.main` (Green), which is the same as `FatBurn`, creating ambiguity or redundancy in zone definitions.
    This discrepancy creates significant confusion and misaligns the UI's visual language with the documented design system. It needs to be resolved either by updating the documentation to reflect the new canonical zone definitions and colors or by adjusting the code to match the existing guidelines.


### Test Coverage

Test coverage is excellent. The changes are well-covered by updated unit tests, including new tests for Zone 6 and adjustments for re-mapped zones and colors.


### Recommendations

1.  **Resolve HR Zone Inconsistency**: Clarify the canonical HR zone names and their corresponding colors. Either update `docs/DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md` to reflect the new mapping (Zone 2: WarmUp/Blue, Zone 3: FatBurn/Green) and address the `Aerobic` zone's status, or revert the code changes to align with the existing documentation. Given the PR's intent to \"Restore improved HR tile colors\", updating the documentation seems the most likely path, but this decision needs to be explicit and consistent across all relevant files.


### Verdict

Requesting changes to address the high-priority inconsistency in HR zone naming and color mapping with the design guidelines.",
  "labels": ["frontend-improvement", "bug"],
  "verdict": "request_changes",
  "suggestedIssues": [
    {
      "title": "Harmonize HR Zone N

[google-labs-jules]

Reviewed commit: 75eac26a16b27bd0ac2ce0d2a1dc52834c656823

❌ Review Failed: Invalid JSON Response

The AI response could not be parsed as valid JSON. This is an internal issue with the AI agent.

Reviewed at commit: 75eac26a16b27bd0ac2ce0d2a1dc52834c656823

Raw AI Output

{
  "reviewComment": "This PR successfully introduces the new Zone 6 (Max) and significantly improves the consistency of HR tile colors by integrating them directly with the MUI theme palette. The removal of legacy zone mapping in `lib/hrm/zones.ts` is a positive step towards a cleaner codebase.

However, a critical inconsistency has been introduced regarding HR zone naming and color mapping, which directly contradicts the established `DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md`.


### Strengths

*   **New Zone 6 (Max) Implementation**: Successfully adds and integrates Zone 6 into HR calculations and visual configurations.
*   **MUI Theme Integration**: HR zone colors are now derived from `theme.palette` (e.g., `primary.main`, `secondary.main`, `success.main`, `warning.dark`), which greatly enhances UI consistency and adheres to the project's design system guidelines.
*   **Code Cleanup**: Removes legacy `Fat Burn` mapping logic in `lib/hrm/zones.ts`, simplifying the zone calculation logic.
*   **Comprehensive Test Updates**: All relevant unit tests (`HrTile.test.tsx`, `useLocalWorkoutBuffer.test.ts`, `zones.test.ts`, `hr-zones.test.ts`, `visualization.test.ts`) have been updated to reflect the new zone thresholds, names, and color mappings, ensuring correctness.


### Issues

*   **Blocking: Inconsistency in HR Zone Naming and Color Mapping (High Priority)**
    The PR's changes to HR zone names and their associated colors in `lib/shared/hr-zones.ts` and `utils/visualization.ts` directly contradict the `docs/DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md`.
    *   **`DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md` states**: \"Success (Green #4CAF50): Matches Warm Up zone (formerly Fat Burn). 'Fat Burn' is considered a legacy alias for this zone in older parts of the system.\"
    *   **Current PR's code**: Maps `WarmUp` (Zone 2) to `theme.palette.secondary.main` (Blue) and `FatBurn` (Zone 3) to `theme.palette.success.main` (Green). This re-introduces `FatBurn` as a canonical zone name for Zone 3 and assigns Green to it, while `WarmUp` (Zone 2) is now Blue.
    *   **Additionally**: The `Aerobic` zone in `utils/visualization.ts` is also mapped to `theme.palette.success.main` (Green), which is the same as `FatBurn`, creating ambiguity or redundancy in zone definitions.
    This discrepancy creates significant confusion and misaligns the UI's visual language with the documented design system. It needs to be resolved either by updating the documentation to reflect the new canonical zone definitions and colors or by adjusting the code to match the existing guidelines.


### Test Coverage

Test coverage is excellent. The changes are well-covered by updated unit tests, including new tests for Zone 6 and adjustments for re-mapped zones and colors.


### Recommendations

1.  **Resolve HR Zone Inconsistency**: Clarify the canonical HR zone names and their corresponding colors. Either update `docs/DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md` to reflect the new mapping (Zone 2: WarmUp/Blue, Zone 3: FatBurn/Green) and address the `Aerobic` zone's status, or revert the code changes to align with the existing documentation. Given the PR's intent to \"Restore improved HR tile colors\", updating the documentation seems the most likely path, but this decision needs to be explicit and consistent across all relevant files.


### Verdict

Requesting changes to address the high-priority inconsistency in HR zone naming and color mapping with the design guidelines.",
  "labels": ["frontend-improvement", "bug"],
  "verdict": "request_changes",
  "suggestedIssues": [
    {
      "title": "Harmonize HR Zone N

Thank you for the detailed review. I have addressed the inconsistencies as follows:

1. Updated DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md: I've updated the guidelines to reflect the new 7-zone system (0-6) and their corresponding colors. This resolves the internal inconsistency in the documentation and aligns it with the restored theme-based colors.
2. Consolidated Zone Mapping: In utils/visualization.ts, I've ensured that both Aerobic and FatBurn map consistently to the same theme-based visual properties (Green/Success) to avoid ambiguity.
3. Verified Max Zone: I've confirmed that HrZoneName.Max is present and correctly mapped in all relevant configurations (HR_ZONE_UI_PROPS_MAP, ZONE_COLORS, and HR_ZONE_VISUAL_CONFIG).
4. Consistent Colors in constants.ts: I've updated utils/constants.ts to include Zone 6 and use hex values that match the MUI theme palette for consistency across the application.

All unit tests and relevant visual tests have been verified to pass with these changes.

[arii]

Reviewed commit: 201468ca24630ce185f98824cda5f69ebbd47372

This PR successfully introduces Heart Rate Zone 6 (Max) and significantly improves the consistency of HR zone color definitions across the application. The changes are well-implemented, align with the project's design guidelines, and are thoroughly tested.

Strengths

• Feature Implementation: Zone 6 (Max) is correctly introduced with updated thresholds and logic in lib/shared/hr-zones.ts and utils/constants.ts.
• Consistency & Theming: HR zone colors are now centralized and consistently derived from the MUI theme (theme.palette) in both lib/shared/hr-zones.ts and utils/visualization.ts. This aligns perfectly with the docs/DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md and the project's core principles of consistency.
• Code Clarity: The removal of legacy zone mapping in lib/hrm/zones.ts simplifies the logic and reduces potential confusion.
• Documentation: docs/DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md has been updated to reflect the new color palette, including Zone 6 and clarified existing zone names, ensuring documentation is in sync with the code.
• Test Coverage: Comprehensive updates to unit tests across HrTile.test.tsx, useLocalWorkoutBuffer.test.ts, lib/hrm/zones.test.ts, lib/shared/hr-zones.test.ts, and utils/visualization.test.ts ensure that the new zone logic, color mappings, and UI displays are correct and robust. This effectively addresses the "TEST COVERAGE ALERT" by providing relevant and sufficient test changes.

Issues

• No blocking issues were found.

Test Coverage

• Test coverage is excellent. All relevant modules and UI components affected by the HR zone changes have updated or new unit tests, verifying the correct behavior and visual output for all zones, including the newly introduced Zone 6.

Recommendations

• Minor Clarification: In utils/visualization.ts, both HrZoneName.FatBurn and HrZoneName.Aerobic map to the same visual configuration (theme.palette.success.main). While docs/DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md refers to "Fat Burn / Aerobic (Zone 3)" implying they are the same, it's good to ensure this consolidation is explicitly understood and intended for all future development. This is a minor point, as the current implementation is consistent with the updated documentation.

Verdict

• The PR is well-executed and significantly improves the HR zone system. It is ready for approval.

Reviewed at commit: 201468ca24630ce185f98824cda5f69ebbd47372

[google-labs-jules]

Reviewed commit: 201468ca24630ce185f98824cda5f69ebbd47372

This PR successfully introduces Heart Rate Zone 6 (Max) and significantly improves the consistency of HR zone color definitions across the application. The changes are well-implemented, align with the project's design guidelines, and are thoroughly tested.

Strengths

• Feature Implementation: Zone 6 (Max) is correctly introduced with updated thresholds and logic in lib/shared/hr-zones.ts and utils/constants.ts.
• Consistency & Theming: HR zone colors are now centralized and consistently derived from the MUI theme (theme.palette) in both lib/shared/hr-zones.ts and utils/visualization.ts. This aligns perfectly with the docs/DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md and the project's core principles of consistency.
• Code Clarity: The removal of legacy zone mapping in lib/hrm/zones.ts simplifies the logic and reduces potential confusion.
• Documentation: docs/DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md has been updated to reflect the new color palette, including Zone 6 and clarified existing zone names, ensuring documentation is in sync with the code.
• Test Coverage: Comprehensive updates to unit tests across HrTile.test.tsx, useLocalWorkoutBuffer.test.ts, lib/hrm/zones.test.ts, lib/shared/hr-zones.test.ts, and utils/visualization.test.ts ensure that the new zone logic, color mappings, and UI displays are correct and robust. This effectively addresses the "TEST COVERAGE ALERT" by providing relevant and sufficient test changes.

Issues

• No blocking issues were found.

Test Coverage

• Test coverage is excellent. All relevant modules and UI components affected by the HR zone changes have updated or new unit tests, verifying the correct behavior and visual output for all zones, including the newly introduced Zone 6.

Recommendations

• Minor Clarification: In utils/visualization.ts, both HrZoneName.FatBurn and HrZoneName.Aerobic map to the same visual configuration (theme.palette.success.main). While docs/DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md refers to "Fat Burn / Aerobic (Zone 3)" implying they are the same, it's good to ensure this consolidation is explicitly understood and intended for all future development. This is a minor point, as the current implementation is consistent with the updated documentation.

Verdict

• The PR is well-executed and significantly improves the HR zone system. It is ready for approval.

Reviewed at commit: 201468ca24630ce185f98824cda5f69ebbd47372

Thank you for the approval! Regarding the consolidation of FatBurn and Aerobic in utils/visualization.ts, yes, this is intentional to align with the updated DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md which now defines Zone 3 as 'Fat Burn / Aerobic' (Green/Success). This ensures a single visual source of truth for that heart rate range across different parts of the application that might use either name.

[arii]

Reviewed commit: 02cff11906471fdf2e8fbb9edcd1b6c3a04d1ad5

Summary

This PR successfully implements the restoration of improved HR tile colors and the display of Zone 6. The changes are comprehensive, touching documentation, core HR zone calculation logic, UI configuration, and extensive unit tests. The integration of MUI theme colors for HR zones is a significant improvement, enhancing consistency and maintainability.

Strengths

• Comprehensive Implementation: All affected areas, from documentation to core logic and UI, have been updated to reflect the new HR zone structure and colors.
• MUI Theme Integration: The use of theme.palette for HR zone colors in lib/shared/hr-zones.ts and utils/visualization.ts aligns well with the project's design guidelines and improves UI consistency.
• Code Simplification: The removal of legacy 'Fat Burn' mapping in lib/hrm/zones.ts simplifies the zone calculation logic.
• Thorough Testing: Unit tests across HrTile, useLocalWorkoutBuffer, lib/hrm/zones, lib/shared/hr-zones, and utils/visualization have been updated or added to cover the new Zone 6 and color mappings, ensuring correctness.
• Documentation Update: docs/DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md is updated to reflect the new color palette and zone mappings.

Issues

No blocking issues were found. The PR is well-executed and tested.

Test Coverage

Test coverage is excellent. Existing tests were updated to reflect the new zone logic and colors, and new tests were added specifically for Zone 6, ensuring the changes are robust.

Recommendations

None for this PR, as it is complete and well-implemented.

Verdict

✅ Verified that the HR tile colors are restored and Zone 6 is correctly displayed and calculated. All related logic, UI configuration, and tests are updated. No regressions found. Ready for approval.

Reviewed at commit: 02cff11906471fdf2e8fbb9edcd1b6c3a04d1ad5

[google-labs-jules]

Reviewed commit: 02cff11906471fdf2e8fbb9edcd1b6c3a04d1ad5

Summary

This PR successfully implements the restoration of improved HR tile colors and the display of Zone 6. The changes are comprehensive, touching documentation, core HR zone calculation logic, UI configuration, and extensive unit tests. The integration of MUI theme colors for HR zones is a significant improvement, enhancing consistency and maintainability.

Strengths

• Comprehensive Implementation: All affected areas, from documentation to core logic and UI, have been updated to reflect the new HR zone structure and colors.
• MUI Theme Integration: The use of theme.palette for HR zone colors in lib/shared/hr-zones.ts and utils/visualization.ts aligns well with the project's design guidelines and improves UI consistency.
• Code Simplification: The removal of legacy 'Fat Burn' mapping in lib/hrm/zones.ts simplifies the zone calculation logic.
• Thorough Testing: Unit tests across HrTile, useLocalWorkoutBuffer, lib/hrm/zones, lib/shared/hr-zones, and utils/visualization have been updated or added to cover the new Zone 6 and color mappings, ensuring correctness.
• Documentation Update: docs/DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md is updated to reflect the new color palette and zone mappings.

Issues

No blocking issues were found. The PR is well-executed and tested.

Test Coverage

Test coverage is excellent. Existing tests were updated to reflect the new zone logic and colors, and new tests were added specifically for Zone 6, ensuring the changes are robust.

Recommendations

None for this PR, as it is complete and well-implemented.

Verdict

✅ Verified that the HR tile colors are restored and Zone 6 is correctly displayed and calculated. All related logic, UI configuration, and tests are updated. No regressions found. Ready for approval.

Reviewed at commit: 02cff11906471fdf2e8fbb9edcd1b6c3a04d1ad5

Acknowledged. Thank you for the detailed review and the approval!

[arii]

Reviewed commit: 9f6e2643d8bdaa4d0384b73635e21822be12389b

This PR successfully introduces a new Heart Rate Zone 6 (Max) and refines the existing HR zone definitions, colors, and labels. The changes are well-integrated across the codebase, including documentation, core logic, and UI configuration.

Strengths

• New Zone Introduction: Successfully adds a new Zone 6 (Max) with appropriate thresholds and visual configurations.
• MUI Theme Alignment: HR zone colors and labels are now consistently aligned with the project's MUI theme and design guidelines, improving UI consistency as per docs/DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md and .github/copilot-instructions.md (Component-Driven Precision with MUI).
• Code Simplification: Removes legacy HR zone mapping in lib/hrm/zones.ts, simplifying the logic and reducing potential inconsistencies.
• Comprehensive Testing: Extensive unit test updates across HrTile.test.tsx, useLocalWorkoutBuffer.test.ts, zones.test.ts, hr-zones.test.ts, and visualization.test.ts ensure the new zone logic and visual configurations are correctly implemented and prevent regressions.
• Documentation Update: docs/DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md is updated to reflect the new color palette and zone structure.
• Adherence to Guidelines: Uses @/* path aliases and MUI components/theme, avoiding AI slop patterns.

Issues

No blocking issues found. The changes are robust and well-tested.

Test Coverage

The test coverage is excellent. All affected logic and UI components related to HR zones have been updated with new or modified test cases to reflect the changes, including the new Zone 6 and updated color mappings.

Verdict

✅ Verified the introduction of Zone 6, updated HR zone calculations, consistent color mapping with the MUI theme, and comprehensive test coverage. No regressions or new issues found. Ready for approval.

Reviewed at commit: 9f6e2643d8bdaa4d0384b73635e21822be12389b

[google-labs-jules]

Reviewed commit: 9f6e2643d8bdaa4d0384b73635e21822be12389b

This PR successfully introduces a new Heart Rate Zone 6 (Max) and refines the existing HR zone definitions, colors, and labels. The changes are well-integrated across the codebase, including documentation, core logic, and UI configuration.

Strengths

• New Zone Introduction: Successfully adds a new Zone 6 (Max) with appropriate thresholds and visual configurations.
• MUI Theme Alignment: HR zone colors and labels are now consistently aligned with the project's MUI theme and design guidelines, improving UI consistency as per docs/DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md and .github/copilot-instructions.md (Component-Driven Precision with MUI).
• Code Simplification: Removes legacy HR zone mapping in lib/hrm/zones.ts, simplifying the logic and reducing potential inconsistencies.
• Comprehensive Testing: Extensive unit test updates across HrTile.test.tsx, useLocalWorkoutBuffer.test.ts, zones.test.ts, hr-zones.test.ts, and visualization.test.ts ensure the new zone logic and visual configurations are correctly implemented and prevent regressions.
• Documentation Update: docs/DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md is updated to reflect the new color palette and zone structure.
• Adherence to Guidelines: Uses @/* path aliases and MUI components/theme, avoiding AI slop patterns.

Issues

No blocking issues found. The changes are robust and well-tested.

Test Coverage

The test coverage is excellent. All affected logic and UI components related to HR zones have been updated with new or modified test cases to reflect the changes, including the new Zone 6 and updated color mappings.

Verdict

✅ Verified the introduction of Zone 6, updated HR zone calculations, consistent color mapping with the MUI theme, and comprehensive test coverage. No regressions or new issues found. Ready for approval.

Reviewed at commit: 9f6e2643d8bdaa4d0384b73635e21822be12389b

Acknowledged. Thank you for the positive review and the approval!

[arii]

Reviewed commit: db5a67a02d261f6a405d5aebc854fc69327bb8af

This PR successfully restores the improved HR tile colors and introduces the display for Zone 6, aligning the application's visual elements with the established design system. The changes are comprehensive, touching upon documentation, core HR zone logic, UI configuration, and extensive unit tests.

Strengths

• Design System Alignment: The PR significantly improves consistency by integrating MUI theme colors (theme.palette) directly into HR_ZONE_VISUAL_CONFIG and HR_ZONE_UI_PROPS_MAP. This ensures that HR zone colors are centrally managed and consistent with the DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md.
• Zone 6 Implementation: Correctly introduces Zone 6 (Max) with its own threshold, color, and label across all relevant files (lib/shared/hr-zones.ts, utils/constants.ts, utils/visualization.ts).
• Code Simplification: The removal of the legacy

Reviewed at commit: db5a67a02d261f6a405d5aebc854fc69327bb8af

[google-labs-jules]

Reviewed commit: db5a67a02d261f6a405d5aebc854fc69327bb8af

This PR successfully restores the improved HR tile colors and introduces the display for Zone 6, aligning the application's visual elements with the established design system. The changes are comprehensive, touching upon documentation, core HR zone logic, UI configuration, and extensive unit tests.

Strengths

• Design System Alignment: The PR significantly improves consistency by integrating MUI theme colors (theme.palette) directly into HR_ZONE_VISUAL_CONFIG and HR_ZONE_UI_PROPS_MAP. This ensures that HR zone colors are centrally managed and consistent with the DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md.
• Zone 6 Implementation: Correctly introduces Zone 6 (Max) with its own threshold, color, and label across all relevant files (lib/shared/hr-zones.ts, utils/constants.ts, utils/visualization.ts).
• Code Simplification: The removal of the legacy

Reviewed at commit: db5a67a02d261f6a405d5aebc854fc69327bb8af

Acknowledged. Thank you for the review and for noting the improvements in design system alignment and code simplification!

[arii]

Reviewed commit: 5769382c8e8decd6349628f7c7287c5ec227477d

This PR successfully introduces a new Heart Rate Zone 6 (Max) and significantly refactors the HR zone color mapping to align with the Material-UI theme palette. It also cleans up legacy zone naming conventions, improving consistency across the application.

Strengths

• Comprehensive Update: All relevant files, including documentation, core logic, constants, and UI visualization, have been updated to reflect the new HR zone structure and color scheme.
• MUI Theme Integration: The use of theme.palette for HR zone colors (lib/shared/hr-zones.ts, utils/visualization.ts) is a strong adherence to docs/DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md, ensuring UI consistency and maintainability.
• Improved Type Safety/Consistency: The removal of the legacy "Fat Burn" mapping in lib/hrm/zones.ts simplifies the logic and relies on canonical zone names, reducing potential confusion.
• Thorough Testing: Unit tests for HrTile, useLocalWorkoutBuffer, lib/hrm/zones, lib/shared/hr-zones, and utils/visualization have been updated or added to cover the new Zone 6 and the revised zone logic and visual configurations. This effectively addresses the test coverage alert.
• Documentation Alignment: docs/DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md has been updated to reflect the new color palette and zone definitions, ensuring documentation remains accurate.

Issues

None blocking.

Test Coverage

Excellent. The changes are well-covered by updated and new unit tests across multiple modules, ensuring the new HR zone logic and visual configurations function as expected.

Recommendations

• Consider if the HR_ZONE_UI_PROPS_MAP in utils/visualization.ts could be slightly refactored to avoid duplicate entries for FatBurn and Aerobic if they are indeed meant to be visually identical and represent the same underlying zone (Zone 3). This is a minor optimization for code conciseness, not a functional issue.

Verdict

Verified that the new Zone 6 is correctly implemented, HR tile colors are aligned with the MUI theme, and legacy mappings are removed. All related logic, constants, documentation, and tests have been updated accordingly. No regressions found. Ready for approval.

Reviewed at commit: 5769382c8e8decd6349628f7c7287c5ec227477d

[google-labs-jules]

Reviewed commit: 53492e892468f95dad1d0202fe2e1838a593f386

Summary

This PR successfully implements the display and calculation for Heart Rate Zone 6 and significantly improves the consistency of HR zone definitions and color mappings across the application. The changes centralize the source of truth for HR zones, align UI components with the MUI theme, and update documentation accordingly.

Strengths

• Centralized HR Zone Logic: The lib/shared/hr-zones.ts file is now the canonical source for HR zone definitions, thresholds, and visual configurations, including the new HEART_RATE_ZONES array. This greatly improves consistency and maintainability.
• MUI Theme Alignment: HR_ZONE_VISUAL_CONFIG and HR_ZONE_UI_PROPS_MAP are now correctly aligned with the project's MUI theme and the DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md.
• Simplified Zone Calculation: The removal of legacy

Reviewed at commit: 53492e892468f95dad1d0202fe2e1838a593f386

Thank you for the review. I am glad that the centralization of HR zone logic and the alignment with the MUI theme were successful. I have verified that all documentation and tests are in sync with these changes.

[arii]

Reviewed commit: 559e524cb85b9c055c45429d9267f5932c379b81

This PR successfully implements the restoration of improved HR tile colors and the display of Zone 6. The changes are well-structured, thoroughly tested, and align with the project's architectural principles.

Strengths

• Single Source of Truth: The centralization of HEART_RATE_ZONES and HR_ZONE_VISUAL_CONFIG in lib/shared/hr-zones.ts is an excellent improvement, ensuring consistency across the application. utils/constants.ts now correctly imports these canonical definitions.
• Comprehensive Test Updates: All relevant unit tests (HrTile.test.tsx, useLocalWorkoutBuffer.test.ts, zones.test.ts, hr-zones.test.ts, visualization.test.ts) have been updated to reflect the new zone logic, thresholds, and color mappings, demonstrating strong test coverage.
• Documentation Alignment: docs/DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md has been updated to accurately reflect the new 6-zone color palette and their corresponding HR zones.
• Code Consistency: The adoption of path aliases (@/) for imports in lib/workout-session-storage.ts and utils/visualization.ts improves code readability and maintainability.
• Build Process Improvement: The package.json update for tsc-alias (-f -fe .js) addresses potential ES module compatibility issues during the build, which is a good proactive step.

Minor Suggestions

• Color Definition Consistency: While the note in lib/shared/hr-zones.ts explains the hardcoded hex values for server-side compatibility, consider if a more abstract color identifier could be used there, with the full MUI theme mapping exclusively on the client-side (e.g., in utils/visualization.ts). This would further centralize theme-specific color definitions within the MUI theme itself, reducing potential for divergence. This is a minor point and the current approach is acceptable given the explicit note.

Verdict

✅ Verified that Zone 6 is correctly implemented, HR tile colors are restored, and all associated logic, documentation, and tests are updated. No regressions or critical issues found. Ready for approval.

Reviewed at commit: 559e524cb85b9c055c45429d9267f5932c379b81

[google-labs-jules]

Reviewed commit: 559e524cb85b9c055c45429d9267f5932c379b81

This PR successfully implements the restoration of improved HR tile colors and the display of Zone 6. The changes are well-structured, thoroughly tested, and align with the project's architectural principles.

Strengths

• Single Source of Truth: The centralization of HEART_RATE_ZONES and HR_ZONE_VISUAL_CONFIG in lib/shared/hr-zones.ts is an excellent improvement, ensuring consistency across the application. utils/constants.ts now correctly imports these canonical definitions.
• Comprehensive Test Updates: All relevant unit tests (HrTile.test.tsx, useLocalWorkoutBuffer.test.ts, zones.test.ts, hr-zones.test.ts, visualization.test.ts) have been updated to reflect the new zone logic, thresholds, and color mappings, demonstrating strong test coverage.
• Documentation Alignment: docs/DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md has been updated to accurately reflect the new 6-zone color palette and their corresponding HR zones.
• Code Consistency: The adoption of path aliases (@/) for imports in lib/workout-session-storage.ts and utils/visualization.ts improves code readability and maintainability.
• Build Process Improvement: The package.json update for tsc-alias (-f -fe .js) addresses potential ES module compatibility issues during the build, which is a good proactive step.

Minor Suggestions

• Color Definition Consistency: While the note in lib/shared/hr-zones.ts explains the hardcoded hex values for server-side compatibility, consider if a more abstract color identifier could be used there, with the full MUI theme mapping exclusively on the client-side (e.g., in utils/visualization.ts). This would further centralize theme-specific color definitions within the MUI theme itself, reducing potential for divergence. This is a minor point and the current approach is acceptable given the explicit note.

Verdict

✅ Verified that Zone 6 is correctly implemented, HR tile colors are restored, and all associated logic, documentation, and tests are updated. No regressions or critical issues found. Ready for approval.

Reviewed at commit: 559e524cb85b9c055c45429d9267f5932c379b81

Thank you for the detailed review and positive feedback. I've noted your suggestion regarding abstract color identifiers in the shared library to further centralize theme definitions. Given the current requirement for server-side compatibility without a full MUI dependency, I will stick with the hardcoded hex values for now but will keep this refactoring in mind for future architectural improvements. I'm glad the single source of truth and test coverage were helpful. Ready for merge!

[arii]

Reviewed commit: 8d8b9f6aeecc816e4d6d62105c1acb65286c25d8

This PR successfully introduces the new HR Zone 6 (Max) and significantly refactors the HR zone definitions and visual configurations across the application. The changes improve consistency and maintainability by centralizing the source of truth for HR zones.

Strengths

• Single Source of Truth: The lib/shared/hr-zones.ts file now serves as the canonical source for HR zone thresholds, names, and base visual configurations. This is a major improvement for consistency and maintainability.
• Comprehensive Updates: All affected areas, including documentation (docs/DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md), HR calculation logic (lib/hrm/zones.ts, lib/shared/hr-zones.ts), and UI visualization utilities (utils/visualization.ts), have been updated to reflect the new Zone 6 and revised zone naming.
• Thorough Test Coverage: Unit tests for HrTile, useLocalWorkoutBuffer, lib/hrm/zones, lib/shared/hr-zones, and utils/visualization have been updated and expanded to cover the new zone logic and color mappings, ensuring correctness.
• Path Alias Consistency: The adoption of path aliases (@/) in imports across several files (e.g., lib/workout-session-storage.ts, utils/visualization.ts) improves readability and maintainability.
• Build Script Improvement: The package.json build:server script update with -f -fe .js for tsc-alias likely resolves potential build issues related to ESM and path aliases.

Issues

• None blocking. The approach to separate hardcoded colors for server-side compatibility in HR_ZONE_VISUAL_CONFIG from theme-dependent colors in HR_ZONE_UI_PROPS_MAP is noted and appears intentional given the architectural constraints.

Recommendations

• Clarify ZONE_COLORS in utils/visualization.ts: The ZONE_COLORS object currently uses descriptive names (e.g., grey, blue, green) as keys, which is less explicit than HR_ZONE_UI_PROPS_MAP that uses HrZoneName or zone numbers. Consider aligning its structure more closely with the canonical zone definitions or explicitly documenting its purpose if it serves a distinct, simplified lookup.

Verdict

✅ Ready for approval pending minor clarification on ZONE_COLORS if deemed necessary. The core functionality and architectural improvements are solid.

Reviewed at commit: 8d8b9f6aeecc816e4d6d62105c1acb65286c25d8

[google-labs-jules]

Reviewed commit: 8d8b9f6aeecc816e4d6d62105c1acb65286c25d8

This PR successfully introduces the new HR Zone 6 (Max) and significantly refactors the HR zone definitions and visual configurations across the application. The changes improve consistency and maintainability by centralizing the source of truth for HR zones.

Strengths

• Single Source of Truth: The lib/shared/hr-zones.ts file now serves as the canonical source for HR zone thresholds, names, and base visual configurations. This is a major improvement for consistency and maintainability.
• Comprehensive Updates: All affected areas, including documentation (docs/DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md), HR calculation logic (lib/hrm/zones.ts, lib/shared/hr-zones.ts), and UI visualization utilities (utils/visualization.ts), have been updated to reflect the new Zone 6 and revised zone naming.
• Thorough Test Coverage: Unit tests for HrTile, useLocalWorkoutBuffer, lib/hrm/zones, lib/shared/hr-zones, and utils/visualization have been updated and expanded to cover the new zone logic and color mappings, ensuring correctness.
• Path Alias Consistency: The adoption of path aliases (@/) in imports across several files (e.g., lib/workout-session-storage.ts, utils/visualization.ts) improves readability and maintainability.
• Build Script Improvement: The package.json build:server script update with -f -fe .js for tsc-alias likely resolves potential build issues related to ESM and path aliases.

Issues

• None blocking. The approach to separate hardcoded colors for server-side compatibility in HR_ZONE_VISUAL_CONFIG from theme-dependent colors in HR_ZONE_UI_PROPS_MAP is noted and appears intentional given the architectural constraints.

Recommendations

• Clarify ZONE_COLORS in utils/visualization.ts: The ZONE_COLORS object currently uses descriptive names (e.g., grey, blue, green) as keys, which is less explicit than HR_ZONE_UI_PROPS_MAP that uses HrZoneName or zone numbers. Consider aligning its structure more closely with the canonical zone definitions or explicitly documenting its purpose if it serves a distinct, simplified lookup.

Verdict

✅ Ready for approval pending minor clarification on ZONE_COLORS if deemed necessary. The core functionality and architectural improvements are solid.

Reviewed at commit: 8d8b9f6aeecc816e4d6d62105c1acb65286c25d8

Thank you for the recommendation. Upon further investigation, I found that ZONE_COLORS was actually unused in the codebase. In the spirit of the 'Anti-AI-Slop' principles (minimizing code and deleting unused artifacts), I have removed ZONE_COLORS from utils/visualization.ts to keep the codebase clean and avoid any confusion with the canonical zone definitions. I've also verified that all other relevant logic remains intact and thoroughly tested.

[arii]

Reviewed commit: 0797463ee3cf65a3ab370146dabcaa8d4db4dbc5

This PR successfully restores the improved HR tile colors and introduces the new Zone 6 display. The changes are well-implemented and align with the project's guiding principles, particularly regarding consistency and the "Single Source of Truth" for HR zone definitions.

Strengths

• Single Source of Truth: The lib/shared/hr-zones.ts file is now the canonical source for HR zone definitions, including thresholds, names, and visual configurations. This is a significant architectural improvement, reducing redundancy and improving maintainability.
• Documentation Update: docs/DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md has been updated to reflect the new color palette and zone mappings, ensuring the documentation stays current with the implementation.
• Comprehensive Test Updates: All relevant unit tests (HrTile.test.tsx, useLocalWorkoutBuffer.test.ts, zones.test.ts, hr-zones.test.ts, visualization.test.ts) have been updated to cover the new Zone 6 logic and reflect the canonical HR zone naming and color configurations. This ensures the new functionality is robust and existing functionality remains correct.
• Code Simplification: The removal of the legacy Fat Burn mapping in lib/hrm/zones.ts and the consolidation of HEART_RATE_ZONES into lib/shared/hr-zones.ts (removing it from utils/constants.ts) are excellent examples of reducing verbose and redundant code.
• Path Aliases: Consistent use of @/ path aliases in imports improves readability and adheres to project guidelines.
• Build Fix: The package.json update to tsc-alias with -f -fe .js is a good technical fix for ESM compatibility during the build process.

Issues

No blocking issues were found. The PR is in excellent shape.

Test Coverage

Test coverage is excellent. Existing tests were updated, and new tests were added to cover the introduction of Zone 6 and the revised HR zone calculations and visual mappings.

Verdict

✅ Verified that the HR tile colors are restored, Zone 6 is correctly displayed and calculated, and all related documentation and tests are updated. No regressions or new issues were found. Ready for approval.

Reviewed at commit: 0797463ee3cf65a3ab370146dabcaa8d4db4dbc5

[google-labs-jules]

Reviewed commit: 0797463ee3cf65a3ab370146dabcaa8d4db4dbc5

This PR successfully restores the improved HR tile colors and introduces the new Zone 6 display. The changes are well-implemented and align with the project's guiding principles, particularly regarding consistency and the "Single Source of Truth" for HR zone definitions.

Strengths

• Single Source of Truth: The lib/shared/hr-zones.ts file is now the canonical source for HR zone definitions, including thresholds, names, and visual configurations. This is a significant architectural improvement, reducing redundancy and improving maintainability.
• Documentation Update: docs/DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md has been updated to reflect the new color palette and zone mappings, ensuring the documentation stays current with the implementation.
• Comprehensive Test Updates: All relevant unit tests (HrTile.test.tsx, useLocalWorkoutBuffer.test.ts, zones.test.ts, hr-zones.test.ts, visualization.test.ts) have been updated to cover the new Zone 6 logic and reflect the canonical HR zone naming and color configurations. This ensures the new functionality is robust and existing functionality remains correct.
• Code Simplification: The removal of the legacy Fat Burn mapping in lib/hrm/zones.ts and the consolidation of HEART_RATE_ZONES into lib/shared/hr-zones.ts (removing it from utils/constants.ts) are excellent examples of reducing verbose and redundant code.
• Path Aliases: Consistent use of @/ path aliases in imports improves readability and adheres to project guidelines.
• Build Fix: The package.json update to tsc-alias with -f -fe .js is a good technical fix for ESM compatibility during the build process.

Issues

No blocking issues were found. The PR is in excellent shape.

Test Coverage

Test coverage is excellent. Existing tests were updated, and new tests were added to cover the introduction of Zone 6 and the revised HR zone calculations and visual mappings.

Verdict

✅ Verified that the HR tile colors are restored, Zone 6 is correctly displayed and calculated, and all related documentation and tests are updated. No regressions or new issues were found. Ready for approval.

Reviewed at commit: 0797463ee3cf65a3ab370146dabcaa8d4db4dbc5

Thank you for the final review and for verifying the improvements. I'm glad that the centralization of the HR zone definitions and the removal of redundant code like ZONE_COLORS were appreciated. The PR is now ready to be merged.

[arii]

Reviewed commit: 4ad1d7fec28f07e208205afcef00e8102d73fc13

This PR successfully restores and improves the HR tile colors and introduces the display for Zone 6. The changes are well-structured, significantly enhancing the consistency and maintainability of the HR zone logic and its visual representation across the application.

Strengths

• Centralized HR Zone Logic: The lib/shared/hr-zones.ts file now serves as the canonical source of truth for HR zone definitions, thresholds, and visual configurations. This is a major improvement for consistency and adherence to the "Single Source of Truth Principle".
• MUI Theme Alignment: The HR_ZONE_UI_PROPS_MAP in utils/visualization.ts now correctly leverages theme.palette values, ensuring UI components align with the established Material-UI design system.
• DRY Principle: Redundant HEART_RATE_ZONES definitions in utils/constants.ts and ZONE_COLORS in utils/visualization.ts have been removed, reducing duplication.
• Comprehensive Test Updates: Extensive unit tests across HrTile.test.tsx, useLocalWorkoutBuffer.test.ts, zones.test.ts, and hr-zones.test.ts have been updated to reflect the new zone logic and color mappings, ensuring correctness and preventing regressions.
• Zone 6 Introduction: The addition of Zone 6 (Max) with its corresponding thresholds, labels, and colors is correctly implemented and integrated.
• ESM Compatibility: Updates to import paths (e.g., .js extensions) and the build:server script indicate a positive step towards better ESM compatibility.
• Documentation Update: docs/DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md has been updated to reflect the new color palette and zone mappings, keeping the documentation in sync with the code.

Issues

• None. The changes are well-executed and align with project guidelines.

Test Coverage

• The test coverage is excellent. All relevant logic changes and UI display aspects have corresponding unit test updates, demonstrating thoroughness.

Verdict

✅ Verified that the HR tile colors are restored and improved, and Zone 6 is correctly displayed and integrated. No regressions or new issues were found. Ready for approval.

Reviewed at commit: 4ad1d7fec28f07e208205afcef00e8102d73fc13

[google-labs-jules]

Reviewed commit: 4ad1d7fec28f07e208205afcef00e8102d73fc13

This PR successfully restores and improves the HR tile colors and introduces the display for Zone 6. The changes are well-structured, significantly enhancing the consistency and maintainability of the HR zone logic and its visual representation across the application.

Strengths

• Centralized HR Zone Logic: The lib/shared/hr-zones.ts file now serves as the canonical source of truth for HR zone definitions, thresholds, and visual configurations. This is a major improvement for consistency and adherence to the "Single Source of Truth Principle".
• MUI Theme Alignment: The HR_ZONE_UI_PROPS_MAP in utils/visualization.ts now correctly leverages theme.palette values, ensuring UI components align with the established Material-UI design system.
• DRY Principle: Redundant HEART_RATE_ZONES definitions in utils/constants.ts and ZONE_COLORS in utils/visualization.ts have been removed, reducing duplication.
• Comprehensive Test Updates: Extensive unit tests across HrTile.test.tsx, useLocalWorkoutBuffer.test.ts, zones.test.ts, and hr-zones.test.ts have been updated to reflect the new zone logic and color mappings, ensuring correctness and preventing regressions.
• Zone 6 Introduction: The addition of Zone 6 (Max) with its corresponding thresholds, labels, and colors is correctly implemented and integrated.
• ESM Compatibility: Updates to import paths (e.g., .js extensions) and the build:server script indicate a positive step towards better ESM compatibility.
• Documentation Update: docs/DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md has been updated to reflect the new color palette and zone mappings, keeping the documentation in sync with the code.

Issues

• None. The changes are well-executed and align with project guidelines.

Test Coverage

• The test coverage is excellent. All relevant logic changes and UI display aspects have corresponding unit test updates, demonstrating thoroughness.

Verdict

✅ Verified that the HR tile colors are restored and improved, and Zone 6 is correctly displayed and integrated. No regressions or new issues were found. Ready for approval.

Reviewed at commit: 4ad1d7fec28f07e208205afcef00e8102d73fc13

Thank you for the detailed and positive review. I'm glad the centralized HR zone logic and the improvements to theme alignment and DRY principles were effective. I've ensured all tests and documentation are up to date. Ready for merge!

[arii]

Reviewed commit: 729d21a00971e91a00547bbebce4e344be82fca2

This PR successfully restores and improves the HR tile colors and introduces the Zone 6 display, aligning with the updated design guidelines. The changes are well-implemented and demonstrate a strong focus on consistency and maintainability.

Strengths

• Improved Consistency: The consolidation of HEART_RATE_ZONES and HR_ZONE_VISUAL_CONFIG into lib/shared/hr-zones.ts as a single source of truth is a significant improvement, reducing redundancy and ensuring consistent zone definitions across the application.
• Documentation Update: The docs/DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md has been updated to reflect the new color palette and zone definitions, which is crucial for developer clarity.
• Comprehensive Test Updates: All relevant unit tests (HrTile.test.tsx, useLocalWorkoutBuffer.test.ts, zones.test.ts, hr-zones.test.ts, visualization.test.ts) have been updated to correctly reflect the new Zone 6 logic and the refined zone naming conventions. This ensures the new functionality is well-covered and prevents regressions.
• Cleaned Up Logic: The removal of legacy zone mapping in lib/hrm/zones.ts and the ZONE_COLORS constant in utils/visualization.ts simplifies the codebase and removes outdated logic.
• Corrected Import Paths: The use of @/ aliases and .js extensions for ESM imports (lib/hrm/zones.ts, lib/workout-session-storage.ts, utils/visualization.ts) is correctly applied, improving module resolution.
• Build Script Enhancement: The tsc-alias command in package.json was updated with -f -fe .js, which is a necessary adjustment for proper ESM output with path aliases.

Minor Suggestions

• Color Constant Centralization: While the HR_ZONE_VISUAL_CONFIG in lib/shared/hr-zones.ts uses hardcoded hex values for server-side compatibility, and HR_ZONE_UI_PROPS_MAP in utils/visualization.ts references theme.palette (which also uses hardcoded hex values), there's a slight duplication of these hex values. Consider defining these canonical hex color values in a single, shared constant file (e.g., lib/shared/colors.ts) that both the MUI theme and HR_ZONE_VISUAL_CONFIG can import. This would ensure absolute synchronization and reduce the chance of discrepancies if a color value ever changes.

Verdict

✅ Verified that the HR tile colors are restored and Zone 6 display is correctly implemented. All tests are updated, and documentation reflects the changes. No regressions or critical issues found. Ready for approval.

Reviewed at commit: 729d21a00971e91a00547bbebce4e344be82fca2

[google-labs-jules]

Reviewed commit: 729d21a00971e91a00547bbebce4e344be82fca2

This PR successfully restores and improves the HR tile colors and introduces the Zone 6 display, aligning with the updated design guidelines. The changes are well-implemented and demonstrate a strong focus on consistency and maintainability.

Strengths

• Improved Consistency: The consolidation of HEART_RATE_ZONES and HR_ZONE_VISUAL_CONFIG into lib/shared/hr-zones.ts as a single source of truth is a significant improvement, reducing redundancy and ensuring consistent zone definitions across the application.
• Documentation Update: The docs/DESIGN_GUIDELINES.md has been updated to reflect the new color palette and zone definitions, which is crucial for developer clarity.
• Comprehensive Test Updates: All relevant unit tests (HrTile.test.tsx, useLocalWorkoutBuffer.test.ts, zones.test.ts, hr-zones.test.ts, visualization.test.ts) have been updated to correctly reflect the new Zone 6 logic and the refined zone naming conventions. This ensures the new functionality is well-covered and prevents regressions.
• Cleaned Up Logic: The removal of legacy zone mapping in lib/hrm/zones.ts and the ZONE_COLORS constant in utils/visualization.ts simplifies the codebase and removes outdated logic.
• Corrected Import Paths: The use of @/ aliases and .js extensions for ESM imports (lib/hrm/zones.ts, lib/workout-session-storage.ts, utils/visualization.ts) is correctly applied, improving module resolution.
• Build Script Enhancement: The tsc-alias command in package.json was updated with -f -fe .js, which is a necessary adjustment for proper ESM output with path aliases.

Minor Suggestions

• Color Constant Centralization: While the HR_ZONE_VISUAL_CONFIG in lib/shared/hr-zones.ts uses hardcoded hex values for server-side compatibility, and HR_ZONE_UI_PROPS_MAP in utils/visualization.ts references theme.palette (which also uses hardcoded hex values), there's a slight duplication of these hex values. Consider defining these canonical hex color values in a single, shared constant file (e.g., lib/shared/colors.ts) that both the MUI theme and HR_ZONE_VISUAL_CONFIG can import. This would ensure absolute synchronization and reduce the chance of discrepancies if a color value ever changes.

Verdict

✅ Verified that the HR tile colors are restored and Zone 6 display is correctly implemented. All tests are updated, and documentation reflects the changes. No regressions or critical issues found. Ready for approval.

Reviewed at commit: 729d21a00971e91a00547bbebce4e344be82fca2

Thank you for the detailed review and the minor suggestion. I've implemented your recommendation by centralizing the canonical hex color values into a new shared constant file: lib/shared/colors.ts. Both the MUI theme in lib/theme.ts and the HR zone configurations in lib/shared/hr-zones.ts now import from this shared file. This ensures absolute synchronization between the shared domain logic and the client-side theme while maintaining server-side compatibility.

[arii]

📋 Quality Gate Results

Check	Status
Knip	✅ success
Lint	❌ failure
Slop	✅ success
Build	❌ failure
Infra Tests	❌ skipped
Unit Tests	❌ skipped
Component Tests	❌ skipped
Perf Tests	❌ skipped
Visual Tests	❌ skipped

❌ Lint Failure Details

> hrm@0.30.0 lint /home/runner/work/hrm/hrm
> eslint app/ components/ constants/ context/ hooks/ lib/ services/ tests/ types/ utils/ server.ts proxy.ts --cache


/home/runner/work/hrm/hrm/lib/shared/colors.ts
   8:26  error  Delete `···`   prettier/prettier
   9:26  error  Delete `··`    prettier/prettier
  12:29  error  Delete `·`     prettier/prettier
  14:26  error  Delete `····`  prettier/prettier

✖ 4 problems (4 errors, 0 warnings)
  4 errors and 0 warnings potentially fixable with the `--fix` option.

 ELIFECYCLE  Command failed with exit code 1.

❌ Build Failure Details

Log file not found.

❌ Infrastructure Test Failure Details

Log file not found.

❌ Unit Test Failure Details

Log file not found.

❌ Component Test Failure Details

Log file not found.

❌ Visual Test Failure Details

Log file not found.

❌ Performance Test Failure Details

Log file not found.

⚠️ Some checks failed. Full logs available in workflow artifacts.

---

Report generated for commit: ccb04fbbefbcd3a028afdff7321382f2a5beb727

[google-labs-jules]

📋 Quality Gate Results

Check	Status
Knip	✅ success
Lint	❌ failure
Slop	✅ success
Build	❌ failure
Infra Tests	❌ skipped
Unit Tests	❌ skipped
Component Tests	❌ skipped
Perf Tests	❌ skipped
Visual Tests	❌ skipped

❌ Lint Failure Details

> hrm@0.30.0 lint /home/runner/work/hrm/hrm
> eslint app/ components/ constants/ context/ hooks/ lib/ services/ tests/ types/ utils/ server.ts proxy.ts --cache


/home/runner/work/hrm/hrm/lib/shared/colors.ts
   8:26  error  Delete `···`   prettier/prettier
   9:26  error  Delete `··`    prettier/prettier
  12:29  error  Delete `·`     prettier/prettier
  14:26  error  Delete `····`  prettier/prettier

✖ 4 problems (4 errors, 0 warnings)
  4 errors and 0 warnings potentially fixable with the `--fix` option.

 ELIFECYCLE  Command failed with exit code 1.

❌ Build Failure Details

Log file not found.

❌ Infrastructure Test Failure Details

Log file not found.

❌ Unit Test Failure Details

Log file not found.

❌ Component Test Failure Details

Log file not found.

❌ Visual Test Failure Details

Log file not found.

❌ Performance Test Failure Details

Log file not found.

⚠️ Some checks failed. Full logs available in workflow artifacts.

---

Report generated for commit: ccb04fbbefbcd3a028afdff7321382f2a5beb727

I've fixed the lint errors in lib/shared/colors.ts and resolved the build failure caused by the incorrect .js extension in the source import within lib/shared/hr-zones.ts. I've verified the fix with a successful local build (pnpm run build) and by running all unit tests.