Review and triage 27 open issues and 12 PRs for obsolescence

[Copilot]

Analyzed all open issues and PRs against current codebase (v2.3.2) to identify obsolete items and prioritize remaining work.

Key Findings

Schema Registration Conflicts: Issues #41, #37, #44 and PRs #46, #43, #40 all address the same tool validation problem. Current code already uses .shape extraction (line 179 in raindropmcp.service.ts). These items need user verification with v2.3.2 or closure.

Resolved Features: Issues #31 (declarative tools), #30 (diagnostics), #28 (tag management) are implemented in current modular architecture (src/tools/). Can close immediately.

Anthropic Blocker: Issue #36 contains Claude Desktop submission requirements (manifest schema compliance, privacy policies, destructive tool hints). High priority for integration.

Valid Enhancements: 10 issues represent unimplemented features (resource linking, pagination, advanced search, batch ops). Kept open as backlog.

Deliverable

ISSUE_PR_REVIEW.md - Comprehensive triage document with:

• Status assessment for each issue/PR (Resolved/Needs Verification/Valid Enhancement/Obsolete)
• Actionable recommendations with priority matrix
• Summary statistics and testing checklist
• Categorization by urgency and type

Immediate Actions

1. Close resolved issues: Declarative Tool Registration #31, Error Reporting & Diagnostics Tool #30, Tag Management Tools #28
2. Request user verification on v2.3.2: MCP Protocol Validation Error: All tools have invalid inputSchema.type (not "object") #41, "No tools available" in Claude Desktop #37, No tools showing #44, bookmark_search API endpoint returns 404 error for all search operations #23, Error when installing with npx #22
3. Resolve PR conflicts: Choose schema approach and close duplicates (Fix tool inputSchema type conversion causing MCP clients to reject tools #46, fix: add exact tag matching and bulk edit authorization #43, Fix: Resolve MCP SDK compatibility issues and improve tool handlers #40)
4. Address Anthropic requirements: Claude Desktop extension submission feedback #36

---

✨ Let Copilot coding agent set things up for you — coding agent works faster and does higher quality work when set up for your repo.