Skip to content

Conversation

@tbrown91
Copy link
Collaborator

Assembly review request

  • ToLID: uoHydFoet1
  • Species: Hydrurus foetidus
  • Project: ERGA-BGE
  • Affiliation: IZW

@erga-ear-bot
Copy link
Contributor

erga-ear-bot bot commented Nov 27, 2025

Hi @tbrown91, thanks for sending the EAR of Hydrurus foetidus.
I added the corresponding tag to the PR and will contact a supervisor and a reviewer ASAP.

@erga-ear-bot
Copy link
Contributor

erga-ear-bot bot commented Nov 27, 2025

Hi @additive3, do you agree to supervise this assembly?
Please reply to this message only with OK to give acknowledge.

@additive3
Copy link
Collaborator

additive3 commented Nov 27, 2025 via email

@erga-ear-bot
Copy link
Contributor

erga-ear-bot bot commented Nov 27, 2025

*****
EAR Reviewer Selection Process
Date: 2025-11-27 11:47

All Eligible Candidates:

Github ID     | Full Name             | Institution | Total Reviews | Last Review | Active | Working PRs | Calling Score | Adjusted Score
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
andar27       | Adama Ndar            | Genoscope   | 8             | 2025-11-26  | Y      | 1           | 1044          | 1074          
CaroB-M       | Caroline Menguy       | Genoscope   | 13            | 2025-11-26  | Y      | 1           | 1040          | 1070          
additive3     | Jo Wood               | Sanger      | 8             | 2025-10-17  | Y      | 0           | 1017          | 1062          
bistace       | Benjamin Istace       | Genoscope   | 7             | 2025-10-17  | Y      | 2           | 1046          | 1056          
jesgomez      | Jessica Gomez Garrido | CNAG        | 12            | 2025-11-26  | Y      | 1           | 1026          | 1056          
gitcruz       | Fernando Cruz         | CNAG        | 13            | 2025-11-17  | Y      | 1           | 1025          | 1055          
MartinPippel  | Martin Pippel         | SciLifeLab  | 2             | 2025-10-06  | Y      | 1           | 1021          | 1051          
ldemirdj      | Lola Demirdjian       | Genoscope   | 11            | 2025-10-14  | Y      | 2           | 1041          | 1051          
auryjm        | Jean-Marc Aury        | Genoscope   | 12            | 2025-11-18  | Y      | 2           | 1040          | 1050          
EmilieTeo     | Emilie Teodori        | Genoscope   | 12            | 2025-11-21  | Y      | 2           | 1040          | 1050          
gbdias        | Guilherme Dias        | SciLifeLab  | 4             | 2025-11-19  | Y      | 1           | 1019          | 1049          
SarahPelan    | Sarah Pelan           | Sanger      | 6             | 2025-09-16  | Y      | 1           | 1019          | 1049          
joannacollins | Jo Collins            | Sanger      | 6             | 2025-10-10  | Y      | 1           | 1019          | 1049          
tommathers    | Tom Mathers           | Sanger      | 7             | 2025-10-16  | Y      | 1           | 1018          | 1048          
DomAbsolon    | Dom Absolon           | Sanger      | 8             | 2025-11-04  | Y      | 1           | 1017          | 1047          
talioto       | Tyler Alioto          | CNAG        | 8             | 2025-10-21  | Y      | 2           | 1029          | 1039          

Selected reviewer: Adama Ndar (andar27)
The decision was based on:
- different institution ('Genoscope')
- active ('Y')
- working on 1 PR(s) currently
- highest adjusted calling score in this particular selection (1074)
  (Note: Adjusted score already considering -20 points due to 1 ongoing PR(s))

@erga-ear-bot
Copy link
Contributor

erga-ear-bot bot commented Nov 27, 2025

Hi @andar27, do you agree to review this assembly?
Please reply to this message only with Yes or No by 03-Dec-2025 at 16:46 CET

@andar27
Copy link
Collaborator

andar27 commented Dec 1, 2025

No

@erga-ear-bot
Copy link
Contributor

erga-ear-bot bot commented Dec 1, 2025

@andar27 Ok thank you, I will look for the next reviewer on the list :)

@erga-ear-bot
Copy link
Contributor

erga-ear-bot bot commented Dec 1, 2025

*****
EAR Reviewer Selection Process
Date: 2025-12-01 10:31

All Eligible Candidates:

Github ID     | Full Name             | Institution | Total Reviews | Last Review | Active | Working PRs | Calling Score | Adjusted Score
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
gitcruz       | Fernando Cruz         | CNAG        | 13            | 2025-11-17  | Y      | 0           | 1025          | 1075          
tommathers    | Tom Mathers           | Sanger      | 7             | 2025-10-16  | Y      | 0           | 1018          | 1068          
jesgomez      | Jessica Gomez Garrido | CNAG        | 12            | 2025-11-26  | Y      | 1           | 1026          | 1056          
andar27       | Adama Ndar            | Genoscope   | 8             | 2025-11-26  | Y      | 2           | 1044          | 1054          
MartinPippel  | Martin Pippel         | SciLifeLab  | 2             | 2025-10-06  | Y      | 1           | 1021          | 1051          
ldemirdj      | Lola Demirdjian       | Genoscope   | 11            | 2025-10-14  | Y      | 2           | 1041          | 1051          
auryjm        | Jean-Marc Aury        | Genoscope   | 12            | 2025-11-18  | Y      | 2           | 1040          | 1050          
EmilieTeo     | Emilie Teodori        | Genoscope   | 12            | 2025-11-21  | Y      | 2           | 1040          | 1050          
CaroB-M       | Caroline Menguy       | Genoscope   | 13            | 2025-11-26  | Y      | 2           | 1040          | 1050          
gbdias        | Guilherme Dias        | SciLifeLab  | 4             | 2025-11-19  | Y      | 1           | 1019          | 1049          
SarahPelan    | Sarah Pelan           | Sanger      | 6             | 2025-09-16  | Y      | 1           | 1019          | 1049          
joannacollins | Jo Collins            | Sanger      | 6             | 2025-10-10  | Y      | 1           | 1019          | 1049          
DomAbsolon    | Dom Absolon           | Sanger      | 8             | 2025-11-04  | Y      | 1           | 1017          | 1047          
additive3     | Jo Wood               | Sanger      | 8             | 2025-10-17  | Y      | 1           | 1017          | 1042          
talioto       | Tyler Alioto          | CNAG        | 8             | 2025-10-21  | Y      | 2           | 1029          | 1039          
bistace       | Benjamin Istace       | Genoscope   | 7             | 2025-10-17  | Y      | 3           | 1046          | 1036          

Selected reviewer: Fernando Cruz (gitcruz)
The decision was based on:
- different institution ('CNAG')
- active ('Y')
- working on 0 PR(s) currently
- highest adjusted calling score in this particular selection (1075)

@erga-ear-bot
Copy link
Contributor

erga-ear-bot bot commented Dec 1, 2025

Hi @gitcruz, do you agree to review this assembly?
Please reply to this message only with Yes or No by 05-Dec-2025 at 15:31 CET

@gitcruz
Copy link
Collaborator

gitcruz commented Dec 1, 2025

No

@erga-ear-bot
Copy link
Contributor

erga-ear-bot bot commented Dec 1, 2025

@gitcruz Ok thank you, I will look for the next reviewer on the list :)

@erga-ear-bot
Copy link
Contributor

erga-ear-bot bot commented Dec 1, 2025

*****
EAR Reviewer Selection Process
Date: 2025-12-01 10:33

All Eligible Candidates:

Github ID     | Full Name             | Institution | Total Reviews | Last Review | Active | Working PRs | Calling Score | Adjusted Score
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
tommathers    | Tom Mathers           | Sanger      | 7             | 2025-10-16  | Y      | 0           | 1018          | 1068          
jesgomez      | Jessica Gomez Garrido | CNAG        | 12            | 2025-11-26  | Y      | 1           | 1026          | 1056          
gitcruz       | Fernando Cruz         | CNAG        | 13            | 2025-11-17  | Y      | 1           | 1025          | 1055          
andar27       | Adama Ndar            | Genoscope   | 8             | 2025-11-26  | Y      | 2           | 1044          | 1054          
MartinPippel  | Martin Pippel         | SciLifeLab  | 2             | 2025-10-06  | Y      | 1           | 1021          | 1051          
ldemirdj      | Lola Demirdjian       | Genoscope   | 11            | 2025-10-14  | Y      | 2           | 1041          | 1051          
auryjm        | Jean-Marc Aury        | Genoscope   | 12            | 2025-11-18  | Y      | 2           | 1040          | 1050          
EmilieTeo     | Emilie Teodori        | Genoscope   | 12            | 2025-11-21  | Y      | 2           | 1040          | 1050          
CaroB-M       | Caroline Menguy       | Genoscope   | 13            | 2025-11-26  | Y      | 2           | 1040          | 1050          
gbdias        | Guilherme Dias        | SciLifeLab  | 4             | 2025-11-19  | Y      | 1           | 1019          | 1049          
SarahPelan    | Sarah Pelan           | Sanger      | 6             | 2025-09-16  | Y      | 1           | 1019          | 1049          
joannacollins | Jo Collins            | Sanger      | 6             | 2025-10-10  | Y      | 1           | 1019          | 1049          
DomAbsolon    | Dom Absolon           | Sanger      | 8             | 2025-11-04  | Y      | 1           | 1017          | 1047          
additive3     | Jo Wood               | Sanger      | 8             | 2025-10-17  | Y      | 1           | 1017          | 1042          
talioto       | Tyler Alioto          | CNAG        | 8             | 2025-10-21  | Y      | 2           | 1029          | 1039          
bistace       | Benjamin Istace       | Genoscope   | 7             | 2025-10-17  | Y      | 3           | 1046          | 1036          

Selected reviewer: Tom Mathers (tommathers)
The decision was based on:
- different institution ('Sanger')
- active ('Y')
- working on 0 PR(s) currently
- highest adjusted calling score in this particular selection (1068)

@erga-ear-bot
Copy link
Contributor

erga-ear-bot bot commented Dec 1, 2025

Hi @tommathers, do you agree to review this assembly?
Please reply to this message only with Yes or No by 05-Dec-2025 at 15:33 CET

@tommathers
Copy link
Collaborator

tommathers commented Dec 1, 2025 via email

@erga-ear-bot erga-ear-bot bot requested a review from tommathers December 1, 2025 10:36
@erga-ear-bot
Copy link
Contributor

erga-ear-bot bot commented Dec 1, 2025

Thanks for agreeing!
I appointed you as the EAR reviewer.
I will track this as one of your Working PRs until you finish this review.
Please check the Wiki if you need to refresh something. (and remember that you must download the EAR PDF to be able to click on the link to the contact map file!)
Contact the PR assignee for any issues.

Copy link
Collaborator

@tommathers tommathers left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

This looks like a really difficult one. The coverage is also very choppy which makes it hard to interpret.

I had a look through and found the following:

SCAFFOLD_1: 1.277 Mb to 1.35 Mb Hap dup

SCAFFOLD_2: Scaffold_74 goes to gap at 11.6 Mb.

SCAFFOLD_3: 4.671 Mb to 4.842 Mb flips.

SCAFFOLD_4: Start to 368 Kb hap dup (it has some repeat but looks like prob alternative version from other hap, coverage is low). Also, 8.465 Mb to 8.5 Mb hap dup.

SCAFFOLD_5: Small hap dup between gaps at 6.5 Mb 6.53 Mb.Flip chunk from 6.27 Mb to 6.5 Mb.

SCAFFOLD_6: Flip chunk from 5.5 Mb to 6.15 Mb.

SCAFFOLD_8: Small hap dups between gaps at 5.78 Mb and 5.28 Mb.

SCAFFOLD_9: Small hap dup between gaps at 1.862 Mb and 1.893 Mb.

SCAFFOLD_9: SCAFFOLD_147 flips and places in gap at 4.5 Mb.

SCAFFOLD_10: not 100% but I would prob remove 5.7 Mb to 5.9 Mb as hap dup / false dup.

SCAFFOLD_14: Small hap dup at gaps at 1.65 Mb.

SCAFFOLD_15: 3.648 Mb to 3.673 Mb hap dup.

SCAFFOLD_16: start to 19 Kb hap dup. Also, 1.33 Mb to 1.37 Mb.

SCAFFOLD_18: Small hap dup at gaps at 3.8 Mb.

SCAFFOLD_19: flip from start to 1.862 Mb then move chunk from 0 to 44Kb to shrapnel, flip chunk from 1.868 Mb to 1.97 Mb. Small hap dup at 2.148 Mb.

SCAFFOLD_20: Scaffold_71 places in gap at 4.124 Mb

SCAFFOLD_22: Flip chunk from 3.234 Mb to 3.514 Mb. Small piece from 3.641 Mb to 3.692 Mb possibly change to unloc or put in shrapnel.

SCAFFOLD_23: Scaffold_92 places in gap at 82 Kb.

SCAFFOLD_24: 3.343 Mb to 3.362 Mb hap dup. Small piece right at end could prob go to shrapnel. Move chunk from 2,99 Mb to 3.063 Mb to end.

SCAFFOLD_27: small hap dup at 749 Kb.

SCAFFOLD_29: Flip chunk from start to 260 Kb.

SCAFFOLD_30: Hap dup at 718 Kb between gaps.ew

SCAFFOLD_33: cmall chunk from start to 33 Kb is hap dup.

SCAFFOLD_36: I think flipping from start to gap at 730 Kb looks slightly better. Also, although coverage is not 100 % conclusive I think unloc_1 is hap dup.

SCAFFOLD_39: I thin tiny bit from start to first gap is hap dup, then flip chunk from 12 Kb to 572 Kb.

SCAFFOLD_76, 77 etc. don’t have much background to main assembly but plssibly just because they are repetitive. I would blast them to double check not contamination.

Shrapnel hap dups: SCAFFOLD_151, SCAFFOLD_111, SCAFFOLD_203, SCAFFOLD_176 (there are prob some others).

@tbrown91
Copy link
Collaborator Author

tbrown91 commented Dec 1, 2025

Thanks @tommathers

Yeah, I didn't have much fun with this one. Thank you for your edits. I'll go through and hopefully get another map to you soon

@tbrown91
Copy link
Collaborator Author

tbrown91 commented Dec 1, 2025

Just some comments, and then I'll make a new HiC map for you. Thank you for going through so thoroughly, I really appreciate it.

SCAFFOLD_5: Flip chunk from 6.27 Mb to 6.5 Mb. This looks worse for me
SCAFFOLD_76, 77 etc. don’t have much background to main assembly but plssibly just because they are repetitive. I would blast them to double check not contamination. These seem to map to a lot of rRNA and mito genes from various stramenopiles. I will do a mito blast to make sure there are not any remaining mito sequences in the assembly

@tommathers
Copy link
Collaborator

Re. SUPER_5. I think it looks better flipped once the hap dup where the marker is in this pic is removed.

image

Then you can flip and get this:

image

Good idea to check for mito in those high cov scaffolds.

@tommathers
Copy link
Collaborator

Also, think there is a hap dup I missed on SCAFFOLD_6 @641 Kb.

@erga-ear-bot
Copy link
Contributor

erga-ear-bot bot commented Dec 5, 2025

Attention @additive3, the EAR PDF was updated.

@erga-ear-bot
Copy link
Contributor

erga-ear-bot bot commented Dec 11, 2025

Ping @additive3,
One week without any movements on this PR!

2 similar comments
@erga-ear-bot
Copy link
Contributor

erga-ear-bot bot commented Dec 19, 2025

Ping @additive3,
One week without any movements on this PR!

@erga-ear-bot
Copy link
Contributor

erga-ear-bot bot commented Dec 26, 2025

Ping @additive3,
One week without any movements on this PR!

@erga-ear-bot erga-ear-bot bot added the DELAYED label Dec 29, 2025
@erga-ear-bot erga-ear-bot bot added the STALLED label Dec 29, 2025
@tbrown91
Copy link
Collaborator Author

tbrown91 commented Jan 5, 2026

Hi @tommathers not sure if you're back yet, but I made some changes to the map. Can you see if you're happy with the assembly?

@erga-ear-bot erga-ear-bot bot removed the STALLED label Jan 5, 2026
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

5 participants