Df 72 theme

[sehyun0518]

• 제목 : feat(issue 번호): 기능명
  ex) feat(17): pull request template 작성
  (확인 후 지워주세요)

🔘Part

• FE

  
  

🔎 작업 내용

• 기능에서 어떤 부분이

• 구현되었는지 설명해주세요

  
  

이미지 첨부

🔧 앞으로의 과제

• 내일 할 일을

• 적어주세요

  
  

➕ 이슈 링크

• [레포 이름 #이슈번호](이슈 주소)

[sonarqubecloud]

Quality Gate passed

Issues
0 New issues
0 Accepted issues

Measures
0 Security Hotspots
0.0% Coverage on New Code
0.0% Duplication on New Code

See analysis details on SonarQube Cloud

[llamapreview]

Auto Pull Request Review from LlamaPReview

1. Overview

1.1 PR Summary

• Business value and requirements alignment: This PR introduces a centralized theming system using Vanilla Extract, encompassing colors, fonts, and shadows. It aims to standardize the design system across the application, ensuring consistent styling and improving maintainability.
• Key components modified: The PR modifies several style-related files, including sprinkle.css.ts, theme.css.ts, and token.ts, to implement the new theming system. It also updates dependencies in package.json and .pnp.cjs.
• Impact assessment: The changes will affect all UI components, enforcing the use of defined theme tokens for styling. This shift requires developers to adopt the new theming approach and the 'sprinkle' utility for styling.
• System dependencies and integration impacts: The new theming system will interact with all UI components, potentially impacting existing components if they are not updated to use the new system.

1.2 Architecture Changes

• System design modifications: The PR introduces a centralized theming system using Vanilla Extract, which includes colors, fonts, and shadows. It also implements a 'sprinkle' utility to enforce the usage of defined theme tokens.
• Component interactions: All UI components will rely on the defined theme tokens for styling. The 'sprinkle' utility will be integrated into component styling to enforce theme adherence.
• Integration points: The theming system will be integrated into the existing UI components, requiring updates to ensure consistency with the new design system.

2. Detailed Technical Analysis

2.1 Code Logic Deep-Dive

Core Logic Changes

• src/styles/sprinkle.css.ts - responsiveProperties
  • Submitted PR Code:

    const responsiveProperties = defineProperties({
        conditions: {
            mobile: {},
            tablet: { '@media': 'screen and (min-width: 768px)' },
            desktop: { '@media': 'screen and (min-width: 1024px)' },
        },
        defaultCondition: 'desktop',
        properties: {
            display: ['none', 'block', 'inline-block', 'flex', 'grid'],
            flexDirection: ['row', 'column'],
            justifyContent: [
                'center',
                'flex-start',
                'flex-end',
                'space-between',
                'space-around',
            ],
            alignItems: ['center', 'flex-start', 'flex-end', 'stretch'],
            placeItems: ['center', 'flex-start', 'flex-end', 'stretch'],
        },
    })

• Analysis:
  • The responsiveProperties define breakpoints for mobile, tablet, and desktop. The defaultCondition is set to 'desktop'. This means that by default, styles applied using these responsive properties will target desktop screens unless overridden by a specific condition.
  • A potential issue arises if a developer intends to apply a style only to mobile or tablet without explicitly specifying the condition. The current setup might lead to unintended desktop-first styling, requiring developers to always think about the desktop case and then override for smaller screens. This could be counter-intuitive for mobile-first development approaches.
• LlamaPReview Suggested Improvements:

    const responsiveProperties = defineProperties({
        conditions: {
            mobile: {},
            tablet: { '@media': 'screen and (min-width: 768px)' },
            desktop: { '@media': 'screen and (min-width: 1024px)' },
        },
        defaultCondition: 'mobile', // Changed defaultCondition to 'mobile'
        properties: {
            display: ['none', 'block', 'inline-block', 'flex', 'grid'],
            flexDirection: ['row', 'column'],
            justifyContent: [
                'center',
                'flex-start',
                'flex-end',
                'space-between',
                'space-around',
            ],
            alignItems: ['center', 'flex-start', 'flex-end', 'stretch'],
            placeItems: ['center', 'flex-start', 'flex-end', 'stretch'],
        },
    })

• Improvement rationale:
  • Technical benefits: Adopting a 'mobile-first' approach by setting the defaultCondition to 'mobile' aligns better with modern responsive design practices. This encourages developers to consider the mobile experience as the base and progressively enhance for larger screens.
  • Business value: Ensuring a good mobile experience is crucial for user engagement and accessibility. A mobile-first approach can lead to better performance on mobile devices as fewer styles need to be overridden.
  • Risk assessment: Changing the defaultCondition might require a review of existing or newly implemented components using these responsive properties to ensure styles are applied as intended.

Core Logic Changes

• src/styles/theme.css.ts - vars
  • Submitted PR Code:

    import { createGlobalTheme } from '@vanilla-extract/css'
    import { colors, shadows } from './token'
    import { futura, pretendard } from './global/globalText.css'

    export const vars = createGlobalTheme(':root', {
        // design system color(neutral, blue, red, yellow, green, teal)
        colors,
        // design system shadow(small, medium, large, xlarge)
        shadows,
        // typography 사용이 아닌 css 변수로 사용이 필요할 경우 -- 미권장
        font: {
            basic: pretendard,
            logo: futura,
        },
    })

• Analysis:
  • The comment // typography 사용이 아닌 css 변수로 사용이 필요할 경우 -- 미권장 indicates a potential point of confusion or misuse. While providing font families as CSS variables might seem convenient, it bypasses the intended usage of the sprinkles utility for applying typography styles. This could lead to inconsistencies in font application and a deviation from the enforced design system. Developers might directly use these CSS variables in their stylesheets, neglecting the predefined font sizes and line heights in token.ts and the typeScaleProperties in sprinkle.css.ts.
• LlamaPReview Suggested Improvements:

    import { createGlobalTheme } from '@vanilla-extract/css'
    import { colors, shadows } from './token'

    export const vars = createGlobalTheme(':root', {
        // design system color(neutral, blue, red, yellow, green, teal)
        colors,
        // design system shadow(small, medium, large, xlarge)
        shadows,
        // typography는 sprinkle을 통해 사용해주세요.
        // font: { // Removed font definitions to enforce sprinkle usage
        //     basic: pretendard,
        //     logo: futura,
        // },
    })

• Improvement rationale:
  • Technical benefits: By removing the font property from the global theme variables, the PR enforces the intended use of the sprinkles utility for managing typography. This ensures consistency in applying font styles (size, weight, lineHeight) defined in the design system.
  • Business value: Maintaining a consistent visual language across the application improves the user experience and reinforces brand identity. Enforcing the use of the design system reduces inconsistencies and potential visual bugs.
  • Risk assessment: Removing this might require a review of existing code that might be directly using these font variables. However, the comment already discourages this usage, suggesting it might not be widely adopted yet.

Core Logic Changes

• src/styles/token.ts - fontSizes
  • Submitted PR Code:

    export const fontSizes = {
        largeTitle: {
            fontFamily: pretendard,
            fontSize: 26,
            lineHeight: '32px',
        },
        title1: {
            fontFamily: pretendard,
            fontSize: 22,
            lineHeight: '26px',
        },
        title2: {
            fontFamily: pretendard,
            fontSize: 17,
            lineHeight: '22px',
        },
        title3: {
            fontFamily: pretendard,
            fontSize: 15,
            lineHeight: '20px',
        },
        headline: {
            fontFamily: pretendard,
            fontSize: 13,
            lineHeight: '16px',
        },
        subHeadline: {
            fontFamily: pretendard,
            fontSize: 11,
            lineHeight: '14px',
        },
        body: {
            fontFamily: pretendard,
            fontSize: 13,
            lineHeight: '16px',
        },
        caption: {
            fontFamily: pretendard,
            fontSize: 10,
            lineHeight: '13px',
        },
        logo: {
            fontFamily: futura,
            fontSize: 10,
            lineHeight: '13px',
        },
    } as const

• Analysis:
  • While the fontSizes object defines different text styles, it redundantly includes the fontFamily within each size definition. This information is already managed at a higher level (potentially through the theme.css.ts or when applying the sprinkle). Repeating the fontFamily here introduces redundancy and could lead to inconsistencies if a future change requires updating the font family. It also increases the verbosity of the token definition.
• LlamaPReview Suggested Improvements:

    import { fonts } from './token'; // Import the fonts object

    export const fontSizes = {
        largeTitle: {
            fontSize: 26,
            lineHeight: '32px',
        },
        title1: {
            fontSize: 22,
            lineHeight: '26px',
        },
        title2: {
            fontSize: 17,
            lineHeight: '22px',
        },
        title3: {
            fontSize: 15,
            lineHeight: '20px',
        },
        headline: {
            fontSize: 13,
            lineHeight: '16px',
        },
        subHeadline: {
            fontSize: 11,
            lineHeight: '14px',
        },
        body: {
            fontSize: 13,
            lineHeight: '16px',
        },
        caption: {
            fontSize: 10,
            lineHeight: '13px',
        },
        logo: {
            fontSize: 10,
            lineHeight: '13px',
        },
    } as const

• Improvement rationale:
  • Technical benefits: Removing the redundant fontFamily from individual font size definitions simplifies the token structure and reduces the risk of inconsistencies. The fontFamily can be applied more centrally, potentially within the sprinkle definition or when the global theme is created. This adheres to the DRY (Don't Repeat Yourself) principle.
  • Business value: Easier maintenance and updates to the design system. If the font family needs to be changed, it can be done in one place instead of updating multiple entries.
  • Risk assessment: This change requires updating how typography is applied using the sprinkles. The typeScaleProperties in sprinkle.css.ts would need to be adjusted to incorporate the fontFamily.

Core Logic Changes

• src/styles/sprinkle.css.ts - typeScaleProperties
  • Submitted PR Code:

    /**
     * typeScaleProperties : 텍스트와 관련된 CSS 속성을 정의
     */
    const typeScaleProperties = defineProperties({
        properties: {
            fontSize: fontSizes,
            fontWeight: fontWeights,
        },
    })

• Analysis:
  • The typeScaleProperties currently only includes fontSize and fontWeight. To fully encapsulate the typography styles defined in token.ts, it should also include lineHeight. Without lineHeight in the sprinkles, developers might resort to setting it manually, leading to inconsistencies with the intended design.
• LlamaPReview Suggested Improvements:

    /**
     * typeScaleProperties : 텍스트와 관련된 CSS 속성을 정의
     */
    const typeScaleProperties = defineProperties({
        properties: {
            fontSize: fontSizes,
            fontWeight: fontWeights,
            lineHeight: Object.fromEntries(
                Object.entries(fontSizes).map(([key, value]) => [key, value.lineHeight])
            ),
        },
    })

• Improvement rationale:
  • Technical benefits: Including lineHeight in typeScaleProperties ensures that all aspects of typography defined in the design system are consistently applied through the sprinkles utility. This prevents developers from manually setting lineHeight, which could lead to inconsistencies.
  • Business value: Consistent typography enhances the visual appeal and readability of the application, contributing to a better user experience.
  • Risk assessment: This change requires updating how typography is applied using the sprinkles. Developers will now be able to apply lineHeight using the sprinkles utility.

3. Critical Findings

Details

3.1 Potential Issues

• 🔴 Critical Issues

  • Inconsistent application of the theme: If the 'sprinkle' utility is not correctly implemented or universally adopted, it could lead to inconsistent application of the theme.

    • Impact: Visual regressions and a lack of uniformity in the UI.
    • Recommendation: Ensure that all components are updated to use the new theming system and the 'sprinkle' utility.

  • Potential for visual regressions: Existing components might not be properly migrated to the new theming system, leading to visual regressions.

    • Impact: User experience issues and potential bugs.
    • Recommendation: Thoroughly test all components across different browsers and screen sizes to ensure consistency.

  • Complexity in understanding and using the 'sprinkle' utility: The 'sprinkle' utility might be complex for developers to understand and use, potentially hindering productivity.

    • Impact: Slower development and potential misuse of the utility.
    • Recommendation: Provide comprehensive documentation and examples to help developers understand and use the 'sprinkle' utility effectively.

  • Over-reliance on global styles: The introduction of a new styling paradigm could lead to unforeseen issues if not thoroughly tested across different browsers and screen sizes.

    • Impact: Unintended style conflicts and visual bugs.
    • Recommendation: Conduct thorough cross-browser and cross-device testing to identify and fix any issues.

• 🟡 Warnings

  • Incorrect usage of the 'sprinkle' utility: Might lead to runtime errors or unexpected styling behavior.

    • Potential risks: Visual inconsistencies and potential bugs.
    • Suggested improvements: Ensure that the 'sprinkle' utility is used correctly by providing clear documentation and examples.

  • Security considerations: While theming itself doesn't directly introduce major security vulnerabilities, ensuring consistent styling can contribute to a more predictable and trustworthy user interface.

    • Potential risks: Inconsistent styling might expose sensitive information.
    • Suggested improvements: Verify that the theme implementation doesn't inadvertently expose sensitive information through styling.

3.2 Code Quality Concerns

• Maintainability aspects: The new theming system introduces a centralized approach to managing styles, which can improve maintainability if used correctly. However, it also introduces new complexities that developers need to understand.
• Readability issues: The 'sprinkle' utility and the new theming system might be complex for developers to understand initially. Clear documentation and examples are essential to mitigate this.
• Performance bottlenecks: While the performance impact of using Vanilla Extract and the 'sprinkle' utility is likely to be minimal, it should be monitored to ensure no significant performance degradation occurs.

4. Security Assessment

Details

• Authentication/Authorization impacts: None identified.
• Data handling concerns: None identified.
• Input validation: None identified.
• Security best practices: Ensure that the theme implementation does not inadvertently expose sensitive information through styling.
• Potential security risks: Inconsistent styling might expose sensitive information.
• Mitigation strategies: Verify that the theme implementation does not inadvertently expose sensitive information through styling.
• Security testing requirements: Conduct thorough testing to ensure that the theme implementation does not introduce any security vulnerabilities.

5. Testing Strategy

Details

5.1 Test Coverage

• Unit test analysis: Ensure that the 'sprinkle' utility and the new theming system are covered by unit tests to verify their functionality.
• Integration test requirements: Conduct integration tests to ensure that the new theming system works correctly with existing components.
• Edge cases coverage: Test edge cases, such as different screen sizes and browser behaviors, to ensure the new theming system handles them correctly.

5.2 Test Recommendations

Suggested Test Cases

  // Example test case for the 'sprinkle' utility
  import { sprinkles } from './sprinkle.css.ts';

  test('sprinkles utility applies correct styles', () => {
    const styles = sprinkles({
      display: 'flex',
      justifyContent: 'center',
      fontSize: 'largeTitle',
    });
    expect(styles).toContain('display: flex');
    expect(styles).toContain('justify-content: center');
    expect(styles).toContain('font-size: 26px');
  });

• Coverage improvements: Ensure that all aspects of the new theming system, including the 'sprinkle' utility, are covered by tests.
• Performance testing needs: Monitor the performance impact of the new theming system to ensure it does not introduce significant performance degradation.

6. Documentation & Maintenance

Details

• Documentation updates needed: Update the documentation to include the new theming system and the 'sprinkle' utility. Provide clear examples and guidelines for developers to follow.
• Long-term maintenance considerations: Ensure that the new theming system is well-documented and that developers are trained on how to use it effectively.
• Technical debt and monitoring requirements: Monitor the adoption and usage of the new theming system to identify any technical debt or areas for improvement.

7. Deployment & Operations

Details

• Deployment impact and strategy: The new theming system should be deployed carefully to ensure that it does not introduce any visual regressions or performance issues.
• Key operational considerations: Monitor the application after deployment to ensure that the new theming system is working as expected and that there are no unintended side effects.

8. Summary & Recommendations

8.1 Key Action Items

1. Ensure consistent application of the theme: Update all components to use the new theming system and the 'sprinkle' utility.
2. Thoroughly test the new theming system: Conduct thorough testing across different browsers and screen sizes to ensure consistency and identify any issues.
3. Provide clear documentation: Update the documentation to include the new theming system and the 'sprinkle' utility, providing clear examples and guidelines.
4. Monitor performance: Monitor the performance impact of the new theming system to ensure it does not introduce significant performance degradation.

8.2 Future Considerations

• Technical evolution path: Continuously improve the theming system based on feedback and usage patterns.
• Business capability evolution: Ensure that the theming system can adapt to future business requirements and design changes.
• System integration impacts: Monitor the integration of the new theming system with existing components and make adjustments as needed.

---

💡 Help Shape LlamaPReview
How's this review format working for you? Vote in our Github Discussion Polls to help us improve your review experience!