Skip to content

Remarks wildtrack_dataset.py #5

@Monceeeeeeeeeeeeef

Description

@Monceeeeeeeeeeeeef

Hi,

I noticed a discrepancy between the get_worldgrid_from_pos function and the instructions provided in the README regarding how positionID should be converted to world coordinates.
Current Implementation:

def get_worldgrid_from_pos(self, pos):
grid_y = pos % 480
grid_x = pos // 480
return np.array([grid_x, grid_y], dtype=int)

In this implementation:

grid_y is calculated using pos % 480.
grid_x is calculated using pos // 480.

According to the README:

The README indicates that the position ID should be interpreted on a 480x1440 grid with X-first indexing, and the formula for converting positionID to world coordinates is:

X = -3.0 + 0.025 * (ID % 480)
Y = -9.0 + 0.025 * (ID // 480)

Discrepancy:

The current implementation appears to be interpreting the grid in a Y-first manner (i.e., grid_y calculated first, then grid_x).
According to the README, the position ID should be interpreted as X-first, meaning the formula should first calculate X (which corresponds to grid_x in the code) using ID % 480 and then calculate Y (which corresponds to grid_y) using ID // 480.

This could lead to incorrect conversions between positionID and grid/world coordinates.
Suggested Fix:

To align with the README, the implementation could be updated to:

def get_worldgrid_from_pos(self, pos):
grid_x = pos % 480 # This corresponds to X in the README
grid_y = pos // 480 # This corresponds to Y in the README
return np.array([grid_x, grid_y], dtype=int)

This should ensure that the conversion between positionID and world/grid coordinates matches the intended X-first indexing described in the README.

Let me know if this makes sense or if there are any other considerations I might have missed.

Thanks!

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions