rubric_coverage.md

Rubric Coverage Report

Coverage: 10/23 ADDRESSED (43%) Threshold: 80% PARTIAL: 11 | GAP: 2 | CRITICAL GAP: 0 Result: FAIL

---

Rubric Items

#	Status	Requirement	Section	Score
R-01	ADDRESSED	Attack taxonomy for autonomous AI agents (extending OWASP/AT	Executive Summary	0.71
R-02	ADDRESSED	Red-team scripts for 4+ attack classes against open-source a	Executive Summary	0.89
R-03	ADDRESSED	Adversarial control analysis applied to agent input/output a	RQ3: Adversarial Control Analysis — Controllability Drives Defense Difficulty	0.88
R-04	PARTIAL	Defensive architecture patterns with measured effectiveness	Architectural Recommendations	0.40
R-05	ADDRESSED	Open-source red-team framework (CLI tool, not just scripts)	Executive Summary	0.67
R-06	PARTIAL	Attacking production/deployed agents (only local controlled	Limitations	0.25
R-07	PARTIAL	Jailbreaking LLMs (prompt injection FOR agent misuse, not ju	RQ1: Attack Taxonomy — What Can Go Wrong?	0.44
R-08	PARTIAL	Training custom models (use existing LLMs as the agent backb	Executive Summary	0.29
R-09	PARTIAL	Multi-agent coordination attacks (stretch goal only)	Architectural Recommendations	0.43
R-10	ADDRESSED	Multi-agent attack chains (Agent A compromises Agent B throu	RQ1: Attack Taxonomy — What Can Go Wrong?	0.62
R-11	PARTIAL	Benchmark suite that others can run against their own agents	Architectural Recommendations	0.43
R-12	PARTIAL	huntr submission if novel vulnerability discovered in LangCh	Executive Summary	0.38
R-13	ADDRESSED	[ ] Attack taxonomy documented (≥5 classes beyond OWASP/ATLA	Executive Summary	0.71
R-14	ADDRESSED	[ ] ≥3 attack classes demonstrated against ≥2 agent framewor	Executive Summary	1.00
R-15	ADDRESSED	[ ] Adversarial control analysis applied to agent I/O archit	RQ3: Adversarial Control Analysis — Controllability Drives Defense Difficulty	0.83
R-16	GAP	[ ] ≥2 defensive patterns tested with measured effectiveness	Executive Summary	0.20
R-17	GAP	[ ] All code in version-controlled repo (GitHub)	RQ1: Attack Taxonomy — What Can Go Wrong?	0.20
R-18	PARTIAL	[ ] CLI tool installable via pip	RQ1: Attack Taxonomy — What Can Go Wrong?	0.40
R-19	ADDRESSED	[ ] FINDINGS.md written with key results + architecture diag	(full text search)	0.67
R-20	PARTIAL	[ ] DECISION_LOG has all tradeoff decisions from every phase	Architectural Recommendations	0.25
R-21	PARTIAL	[ ] PUBLICATION_PIPELINE.md filled and blog draft started	What's Next	0.25
R-22	PARTIAL	[ ] LESSONS_LEARNED.md in govML updated with FP-02 issues an	FINDINGS — Agent Security Red-Team Framework (FP-02)	0.25
R-23	ADDRESSED	[ ] Conference abstract ready for BSides / DEF CON AI Villag	What's Next	0.62

Common Gap Pattern Warnings

The following common rubric patterns were NOT detected in the report:

• distance metric justification
• similarity metric justification
• hyperparameter search range
• hyperparameter sensitivity
• initialization choice
• convergence criteria
• reward function details
• ablation analysis
• noise sensitivity
• suggested improvements