-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 151
Closed
Description
Shouldn't this use the BlockVersion::has_feature() API?
Originally posted by @jcape in #1700 (comment)
In confidential token ids PR, we added this code:
/// Toggles between old-style and new-style extended message
fn compute_extended_message_either_version(
block_version: BlockVersion,
message: &[u8],
pseudo_output_commitments: &[CompressedCommitment],
range_proof_bytes: &[u8],
) -> Vec<u8> {
if block_version >= BlockVersion::THREE {
// New-style extended message using merlin
digest_extended_message(message, pseudo_output_commitments, range_proof_bytes).to_vec()
} else {
// Old-style extended message
extend_message(message, pseudo_output_commitments, range_proof_bytes)
}
}
This is actually not directly related to confidential tokens implementation.
We wanted to change the way the extended message was being computed to follow best practices like domain separation and framing when signing a message.
Reviewers agreed that this is an improvement.
To avoid toggling explicitly on block version values, we could treat this as a feature use_merlin_extended_message_digest or something, which can happen at the same time as the token id change. We need to describe this in an MCIP, either MCIP 25 or another MCIP.
Metadata
Metadata
Assignees
Labels
No labels