Implementation Status: Need SYS-001 and 20 baseline implementations

[ootakazuhiko]

Problem Implementation Status Report

Based on a comprehensive review of the Req2Run benchmark specifications, the following problems are defined but not yet implemented:

❌ Completely Missing Problems (11 total)

Core Problems (2 missing)

• DATA-001 - Real-time Log Aggregation Pipeline (Advanced)
• SYS-001 - Distributed Lock Coordinator (Expert)

Additional Expert-Level Problems (9 missing)

• LANG-001 - SQL-like Query Language Interpreter
• ML-001 - End-to-End ML Pipeline for Time Series Prediction
• RTC-001 - Scalable WebRTC SFU with Recording
• CHAIN-001 - EVM-Compatible Smart Contract Execution Engine
• DB-001 - Redis-Compatible In-Memory Database
• ORCH-001 - Kubernetes-like Container Scheduler
• GQL-001 - GraphQL Federation Gateway
• SERVERLESS-001 - Multi-Language Serverless Execution Environment
• TSDB-001 - High-Performance Time-Series Database
• MESH-001 - mTLS Service Mesh with Traffic Management

⚠️ Missing Baseline Implementations (2 problems)

These problems have YAML specifications but lack baseline implementations:

• CRYPTO-001 - Missing /baselines/CRYPTO-001/ implementation
• NET-001 - Missing /baselines/NET-001/ implementation

📊 Current Implementation Statistics

• Total Problems Defined: 15
• YAML Specifications Created: 4 (26.7%)
• Baseline Implementations Created: 2 (13.3%)
• Completely Missing: 11 (73.3%)

🎯 Suggested Priority Order

High Priority (Core/Advanced problems)

1. DATA-001 - Log Aggregation Pipeline
2. SYS-001 - Distributed Lock Service
3. ML-001 - ML Pipeline
4. GQL-001 - GraphQL Federation

Medium Priority (Complete existing)

1. CRYPTO-001 baseline implementation
2. NET-001 baseline implementation

Lower Priority (Expert-level)

1. LANG-001 - Query Language Interpreter
2. RTC-001 - WebRTC SFU
3. CHAIN-001 - Smart Contract Engine
4. DB-001 - In-Memory Database
5. ORCH-001 - Container Scheduler
6. SERVERLESS-001 - Serverless Runtime
7. TSDB-001 - Time-Series Database
8. MESH-001 - Service Mesh

📝 Next Steps

1. Create YAML specifications for missing problems
2. Implement baseline solutions for each problem
3. Add comprehensive test suites
4. Document implementation guidelines

This issue tracks the overall implementation status. Individual issues should be created for each problem implementation.

[ootakazuhiko]

📊 Updated Implementation Status (2025-08-21)

Thank you for tracking this! The repository has made significant progress since this issue was created. Here's the current accurate status:

✅ Current Implementation Statistics

• Total Problems Implemented: 34 (with YAML specifications)
• Baseline Implementations: 14
• Missing Problems: 1 (SYS-001 only)

📁 Problems by Difficulty

• Basic: 1 problem
  • ✅ CLI-001
• Intermediate: 8 problems
  • ✅ WEB-001, WEB-001-task-api, WEB-010, WEB-011
  • ✅ CRYPTO-001-file-encryption
  • ✅ NET-001
  • ✅ CLI-010
  • ✅ OBS-010
• Advanced: 17 problems
  • ✅ DATA-001, DATA-010, DATA-011
  • ✅ ML-001
  • ✅ GQL-001, FN-001, TS-001
  • ✅ WEB-012, WEB-013, WEB-014
  • ✅ AUTH-010, AUTH-011
  • ✅ DB-010, DB-011
  • ✅ NET-010, NET-011
  • ✅ CLI-011
• Expert: 8 problems
  • ✅ LANG-001, CHAIN-001, DB-001, ORCH-001, MESH-001
  • ✅ CRYPTO-010, CRYPTO-011
  • ✅ RTC-001

❌ Actually Missing Problem

• SYS-001 - Distributed Lock Coordinator (Expert) - tracked in Implement SYS-001: Distributed Lock Coordinator #16

📦 Baseline Implementation Status

Have baselines (14):

• CHAIN-001, CLI-001, CRYPTO-001, DATA-001, DB-001
• FN-001, GQL-001, LANG-001, MESH-001, ML-001
• NET-001, ORCH-001, TS-001, WEB-001

Need baselines (20):

• All problems from Issue 追加問題の提案（18題・カテゴリ別） #35 (WEB-010 through CRYPTO-011)
• WEB-001-task-api, CRYPTO-001-file-encryption
• RTC-001

🎯 Recommended Next Steps

1. Implement SYS-001 (Issue Implement SYS-001: Distributed Lock Coordinator #16)
2. Add baseline implementations for the 20 problems without them
3. Update this issue title to reflect actual status

Most of the problems listed as "missing" in the original issue have actually been implemented! 🎉