-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 0
Split tollbooth and remediation concerns between reconstruct-best-practices and pre-publish-privacy-review #14
Copy link
Copy link
Open
Description
Problem
The reconstruct-best-practices and pre-publish-privacy-review skills have overlapping concerns around content safety when documenting research and design decisions. Currently:
reconstruct-best-practicescontains detailed tollbooth checks, leak remediation guidance, and audience-per-piece evaluation as part of its documentation workflowpre-publish-privacy-reviewfocuses on scanning for PII patterns but doesn't cover the broader content placement and remediation concerns
This creates duplication and unclear ownership of these responsibilities.
Proposed responsibility split
| Concern | reconstruct-best-practices |
pre-publish-privacy-review |
|---|---|---|
| "Who does this content serve?" audience routing | Primary — about where to put documentation | No — pre-publish assumes target is already chosen |
| Tollbooths before commits/pushes/issues | Referenced briefly | Primary — the actual checklist |
| Leak remediation (amend, force-push, delete) | Referenced briefly | Primary — the recovery playbook |
| Personal narrative vs. abstract documentation split | Primary — about documentation quality | Mentioned as a category of concern |
| Reviewing context piece-by-piece against artifacts | Primary — for completeness | Primary — for safety |
| "If the user walked away this minute" exposure test | Referenced | Primary — this is the core safety heuristic |
Work breakdown
- Add tollbooth checklist to
pre-publish-privacy-review— the list of critical moments (commit, push, issue create, shared doc write) where content must be re-evaluated - Add the "walked away" exposure test to
pre-publish-privacy-review— "if the user stopped right now, could this content reach unintended audiences through normal subsequent actions?" - Add leak remediation playbook to
pre-publish-privacy-review— amend/rebase for local commits, force-push for pushed commits, delete-and-recreate for issues/comments, delete releases not just assets - Add "shared or eventually-shared resources" as a category in
pre-publish-privacy-review— Google Docs with edit history, draft releases, etc. - Slim down the corresponding sections in
reconstruct-best-practicesto brief references that point topre-publish-privacy-reviewfor the detailed guidance, keeping only what's needed for the documentation placement workflow - Ensure both skills reference each other where appropriate without duplicating content
Reactions are currently unavailable
Metadata
Metadata
Assignees
Labels
No labels