Skip to content

Why is the Fontes formulation used in the calculation of the ionization cross-section? #480

@wtbarnes

Description

@wtbarnes

As discussed in chianti-atomic/chianti-idl#12, the Fontes calculation is not actually used in the CHIANTI IDL calculation of the direct ionization cross-section. Rather, all direct ionization cross-sections are computed from the scaled cross sections a la Dere (2007). Is there a reason that the Fontes cross-sections are implemented separately here? @pryoung points out in that issue that the Fontes results were used in producing the fits to the H- and He-like ions.

In the process of doing these comparisons in fiasco in wtbarnes/fiasco#360, where I also implement the Fontes cross-section calculation separately, I find significant differences in all of the ionization rates compared to those results from IDL, but especially in the H- and He-like ions (>10%) where the Fontes cross-section is used. Removing this calculation brings the two results into closer agreement (<10%) though there are still other inconsistencies to be worked out.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions