Skip to content

finance offline reproduction: playbook grows >100K tokens; are we supposed to use --use_bulletpoint_analyzer? #11

@meaten

Description

@meaten

Hi, thanks for the project!

I’m reproducing the finance example (task_name=finer, mode=offline). The intermediate playbook/bulletpoints grow very quickly — >100K tokens before 300 examples — and then LLM calls start failing with rate limiting (likely due to prompt size with the entire playbook).

I also noticed curator doesn’t seem to support merging/deleting bulletpoints, so the playbook only grows.

Commands

Without Bulletpoint Analyzer (README):

python -m finance.run --task_name finer --mode offline --save_path results

With Bulletpoint Analyzer:

python -m finance.run --task_name finer --mode offline --save_path results --use_bulletpoint_analyzer

Questions

  1. Is --use_bulletpoint_analyzer required to reproduce the reported finance results? (README doesn’t include it.)
  2. Is this rapid playbook growth expected, or a bug/misconfig?
  3. Curator ignores --playbook_token_budget. Are there recommended settings/strategies to bound playbook size (max bulletpoints, summarization, truncation, etc.)?

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions