Skip to content

Replace flat land intensity ratio with region-specific ratios #1536

@vahid-ahmadi

Description

@vahid-ahmadi

Problem

household_land_value.py applies a single national intensity ratio (0.673) to convert property wealth into land value for all regions. This produces implausibly flat regional land values — London appears mid-table and South West ranks above it, contradicting all official data.

This was identified in PolicyEngine/policyengine-uk-data#314, which documents the full evidence and discrepancies.

What needs to change

In policyengine_uk/variables/household/wealth/household_land_value.py, replace:

property_wealth_intensity = (
    wealth.land.value.aggregate_household_land_value / wealth.property_wealth
)
return property_wealth * property_wealth_intensity + owned_land

With region-specific intensities:

region = household("region", period)
regional_intensity = parameters(period).household.wealth.land.intensity.property_wealth_by_region[region]
return property_wealth * regional_intensity + owned_land

Regional intensity ratios

Derived from MHCLG Land Value Estimates (2023) via the residual method:

land_per_dwelling = mhclg_land_per_ha / dwellings_per_ha  (central scenario)
intensity = land_per_dwelling / avg_house_price            (UK HPI Dec 2025)

Building costs are roughly uniform nationally, so the land share of property value is much higher in expensive areas.

Region HPI avg price Intensity Source
London £551,294 0.85 MHCLG + UK HPI
South East £378,800 0.65 MHCLG + UK HPI
East of England £338,002 0.60 MHCLG + UK HPI
South West £301,226 0.58 MHCLG + UK HPI
West Midlands £246,141 0.52 MHCLG + UK HPI
East Midlands £243,632 0.48 MHCLG + UK HPI
North West £217,428 0.47 MHCLG + UK HPI
Yorkshire £208,447 0.46 MHCLG + UK HPI
Scotland £190,649 0.44 Interpolated from NE/NW
Wales £214,883 0.47 Matched to North West
North East £165,257 0.42 MHCLG + UK HPI

Scotland and Wales are interpolated from the nearest English region by house price (MHCLG covers England only).

These should be added as a new parameter node under household.wealth.land.intensity.property_wealth_by_region.

Data sources

Related

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

No labels
No labels

Type

No type

Projects

No projects

Milestone

No milestone

Relationships

None yet

Development

No branches or pull requests

Issue actions