-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 32
Description
Problem
household_land_value.py applies a single national intensity ratio (0.673) to convert property wealth into land value for all regions. This produces implausibly flat regional land values — London appears mid-table and South West ranks above it, contradicting all official data.
This was identified in PolicyEngine/policyengine-uk-data#314, which documents the full evidence and discrepancies.
What needs to change
In policyengine_uk/variables/household/wealth/household_land_value.py, replace:
property_wealth_intensity = (
wealth.land.value.aggregate_household_land_value / wealth.property_wealth
)
return property_wealth * property_wealth_intensity + owned_landWith region-specific intensities:
region = household("region", period)
regional_intensity = parameters(period).household.wealth.land.intensity.property_wealth_by_region[region]
return property_wealth * regional_intensity + owned_landRegional intensity ratios
Derived from MHCLG Land Value Estimates (2023) via the residual method:
land_per_dwelling = mhclg_land_per_ha / dwellings_per_ha (central scenario)
intensity = land_per_dwelling / avg_house_price (UK HPI Dec 2025)
Building costs are roughly uniform nationally, so the land share of property value is much higher in expensive areas.
| Region | HPI avg price | Intensity | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| London | £551,294 | 0.85 | MHCLG + UK HPI |
| South East | £378,800 | 0.65 | MHCLG + UK HPI |
| East of England | £338,002 | 0.60 | MHCLG + UK HPI |
| South West | £301,226 | 0.58 | MHCLG + UK HPI |
| West Midlands | £246,141 | 0.52 | MHCLG + UK HPI |
| East Midlands | £243,632 | 0.48 | MHCLG + UK HPI |
| North West | £217,428 | 0.47 | MHCLG + UK HPI |
| Yorkshire | £208,447 | 0.46 | MHCLG + UK HPI |
| Scotland | £190,649 | 0.44 | Interpolated from NE/NW |
| Wales | £214,883 | 0.47 | Matched to North West |
| North East | £165,257 | 0.42 | MHCLG + UK HPI |
Scotland and Wales are interpolated from the nearest English region by house price (MHCLG covers England only).
These should be added as a new parameter node under household.wealth.land.intensity.property_wealth_by_region.
Data sources
- MHCLG Land Value Estimates for Policy Appraisal 2023 — residential land per hectare and density by LA
- UK House Price Index Dec 2025 — regional average house prices
- ONS National Balance Sheet 2025 — aggregate constraint
Related
- Regional property wealth calibration: WAS-imputed main_residence_value doesn't match UK HPI by region policyengine-uk-data#314 — regional calibration targets and full evidence table