Skip to content

Amend the Nix Governance Constitution to remove "etc" #193

@philiptaron

Description

@philiptaron

We should pick a more specific phrase instead of "etc" in these two cases:

Vote eligibility

This is for people whose official contributions are not all visible in the NixOS GitHub organisation, but have contributed roughly the equivalent of 25 commits, also counting contributions such as: ... listing including "etc.".

and

Conflict of Interest (CoI) Balance

In case of doubts on what constitutes the same CoI (subsidiaries, grants, part-time work, etc.), .

During the formation of the NCA I gave this feedback and was mildly dismayed when the constitution included it.

Why should we amend it? "etc" gives the impression of an unbounded and uncertain list. In both of these cases, it's not needed.

In the voting eligibility section, remove the "etc" and reword the following sentence from:

After the decisions on exception requests are made, the list of approved requests is also made public.

to the following:

The EC has the sole right to decide to make a decision on eligibility. After a decision on an exception request is made, the approved request is to be made public.

In the CoI section, replace the sentence above with this:

The election committee decides what constitutes a Conflict of Interest, and is charged with understanding whether specific situations are or are not conflicts.

The examples lead away from what's most important: the role of the election committee.


This issue was generated from a review of constitution.md in #156.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions