Skip to content

[BUG] - Incorrect post-processing for Tiara-FC #465

@mcampos16

Description

@mcampos16

Describe the bug
The current implemented post-processing config files for the Tiara-FC benchmark don't produce a good comparison between results. The csv files produced, each corresponding to a single sub-run which defines the shielding material, the energy of the source, the shielding thickness, the offset and the fission cell used for the detector; have a single row of data.
As a result, the output plots do not provide a good comparison between results. For example, this is the produced atlas for the for the concrete shielding, 68 MeV source, and Th-232 detector sub-runs:

Image While results for various shielding thicknesses are available in different csvs, this is not reflected in the resulting atlas.

To Reproduce
Steps to reproduce the behavior:

  1. Produce raw results for Tiara-FC using JADE.
  2. Post-process those raw results also employing JADE.

Expected behavior
I would expect a similar output than for JADE v3, where the csv files produced contained all the shielding thicknesses for a specific shielding material, fission cell, offset and source energy. As a result, the output plots also reflected it:
Image

Screenshots
Provided in previous sections.

Proposed solution
Even if not ideal, the proposed solution would be to create the csv files individually for each sub-run using the apply_to option in the raw config file for Tiara-FC. It would be very convenient to add a "Shielding thickness" column to each csv.
This would still produce csv files with a single row, but assigning them custom names and having added the "Shielding thickness" column would allow for all the different shielding thicknesses for a single shielding material, fission cell, offset and source energy configuration to be plotted together with JADE (having applied the necessary modifications to the atlas config file as well).

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    bugSomething isn't working

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions