Can mod_auth_radius work together with authnz_ldap_module in apache 2.4

[Philippe34]

Hi,

I use on a deprecated machine with apache 2.2 the radius_auth_module and authz_ldap_module authentication modules and it works well together.
I had compiled mod_auth_radius-1.5.8 and I use mod_authz_ldap-0.26-16

My conf looks like:

<AuthnProviderAlias ldap myldap>
    AuthLDAPBindDN ...
    AuthLDAPBindPassword ...
    AuthLDAPURL ...
</AuthnProviderAlias>

<IfModule mod_auth_radius-2.0.c>
AddRadiusAuth ...
AddRadiusCookieValid 5
</IfModule>

<Directory /var/www/html/private>
AuthType Basic
AuthBasicProvider myldap radius
AuthRadiusAuthoritative on
Require valid-user
</Directory>

Now after having upgraded the private application on a new machine with apache 2.4, I try to do the same thing.
If I only use mod_authnz_ldap, the authentication works as expected.
I have compiled and installed mod_auth_radius-1.6.0, but when this module is loaded, the authnz_ldap_module does not work again.
If mod_auth_radius is loaded before authnz_ldap_module, and if I want to authenticate with LDAP, I get an 401 Unauthorized page
If mod_auth_radius is loaded after authnz_ldap_module, and whatever the identifiant, the authentication is a success.
I don't know if radius works at this step, since it must be tested by an another person, but I can conclude that mod_auth_radius is not compatible with authnz_ldap_module.

It also seems that mod_auth_radius is no longer maintained.
Could this ever be fixed or is it worth less if I abandon radius for apache and just keep ldap?

Thank you for your opinion.

Regards

[alandekok]

Unfortunately the module hasn't been updated in a very long time.

But there's no reason I'm aware of why it wouldn't work with another authentication module.

That being said, I don't know much about Apache's internals. I haven't worked with Apache for a very long time. When I did, the debugging output was extremely unhelpful.

So if the module works, great. If not, I don't have the skills or time to look into it. I would suggest just moving to LDAP.

[Philippe34]

@alandekok
I thank you for your feedback.
It also doesn't seem to me that there is the development of a recent radius module anywhere. I will see about using ldap.
Have a nice day