Total Services: 50+ Total Commands: 300+ Current Implementation: 5 services, ~40 commands (15%) MVP Target: 5 services, ~100 commands (25%) Effort to MVP: 100-150 hours (4-5 weeks)
| Service | Status | Core Commands | Priority | Effort |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| S3 | 40% | ls, cp, rm, mb, rb, sync, mv, presign | CRITICAL | 20-30h |
| EC2 | 30% | describe-*, start, stop, reboot, run, terminate, security groups | CRITICAL | 30-40h |
| IAM | 25% | list-*, create/delete user/role, attach/detach policy, create/delete access key | CRITICAL | 25-35h |
| RDS | 0% | describe-*, create/delete, start/stop, modify, snapshots | CRITICAL | 20-30h |
| STS | 20% | get-caller-identity, assume-role, get-session-token | CRITICAL | 5-10h |
Phase 1 Total Effort: 100-145 hours (4-5 weeks)
1. aws sts get-caller-identity (Verify credentials)
2. aws s3 ls (List buckets/objects)
3. aws s3 cp (Copy files)
4. aws s3 sync (Sync directories)
5. aws ec2 describe-instances (List instances)
6. aws ec2 start-instances (Start instance)
7. aws ec2 stop-instances (Stop instance)
8. aws iam list-users (List users)
9. aws iam list-roles (List roles)
10. aws iam attach-user-policy (Add user permissions)
11. aws rds describe-db-instances (List databases)
12. aws lambda list-functions (List functions)
13. aws lambda invoke (Run function)
14. aws cloudformation describe-stacks (List stacks)
15. aws dynamodb list-tables (List tables)
16. aws cloudwatch describe-alarms (List alarms)
17. aws sns publish (Send notification)
18. aws sqs send-message (Send message)
19. aws secretsmanager get-secret-value (Get secret)
20. aws ssm get-parameter (Get parameter)
- S3 (80%)
- IAM (90%)
- EC2 (75%)
- Lambda (70%)
- VPC (70%)
- RDS (60%)
- CloudWatch (65%)
- DynamoDB (50%)
- CloudFormation (55%)
- ECS, ElastiCache, Route53, ELB, and others
- S3: Complete (add sync, mv, presign)
- EC2: Expand (add run-instances, terminate, security groups)
- IAM: Expand (add user/role/policy CRUD)
- RDS: Full basic support
- STS: Complete (add assume-role, get-session-token)
- Covers: 50% of use cases
- Effort: 100-150 hours
- Lambda: Full basic support
- DynamoDB: Full basic support
- CloudFormation: Stack management
- Covers: 70% of use cases
- Effort: 80-100 hours
- CloudWatch: Metrics and alarms
- SNS: Topics and publishing
- SQS: Queues and messages
- Covers: 80% of use cases
- Effort: 60-80 hours
- VPC: Network management
- ELB: Load balancing
- Route53: DNS
- ElastiCache: Caching
- Covers: 85% of use cases
- Effort: 60-80 hours
- All remaining services
- Covers: 100% of use cases
- Effort: 100+ hours
| Pattern | Example | Complexity |
|---|---|---|
| List | aws s3 ls |
Low |
| Describe | aws ec2 describe-instances |
Low-Medium |
| Create | aws iam create-user --user-name john |
Medium |
| Delete | aws s3 rb s3://bucket |
Low |
| Update | aws rds modify-db-instance |
Medium |
| Start/Stop | aws ec2 start-instances |
Low |
| Attach/Detach | aws iam attach-user-policy |
Medium |
| Batch | aws sqs send-message-batch |
Medium-High |
| Query | aws dynamodb query --table-name X |
Medium-High |
| Invoke | aws lambda invoke function |
Low-Medium |
✓ S3: ls, cp, rm, mb, rb
✓ EC2: describe-instances, describe-regions, start, stop, reboot, describe-instance-types
✓ IAM: list-users, list-roles, list-policies, list-groups, list-account-aliases
✓ STS: get-caller-identity
✓ Configure: get, list, interactive configure
☐ S3: sync, mv, presign
☐ EC2: run-instances, terminate-instances, security groups (6 commands)
☐ IAM: Create/delete users/roles/policies, attach/detach (15+ commands)
☐ RDS: All basic operations (10+ commands)
☐ STS: assume-role, get-session-token (2 commands)
☐ Lambda: list-functions, get-function, create-function, invoke, etc.
☐ DynamoDB: list-tables, describe-table, create-table, query, scan, etc.
☐ CloudFormation: list-stacks, describe-stacks, create-stack, etc.
☐ CloudWatch: describe-alarms, get-metric-statistics, etc.
☐ SNS: list-topics, publish, subscribe, etc.
☐ SQS: list-queues, send-message, receive-message, etc.
☐ VPC, ELB, Route53, ElastiCache, etc.
☐ CloudFront, Auto Scaling, ECS, etc.
☐ Secrets Manager, Systems Manager, etc.
| Complexity | Time | Example Commands |
|---|---|---|
| Simple | 30min-1h | ls, describe-, delete, get- |
| Moderate | 1-2h | create-, attach-, list with filters |
| Complex | 4-8h | run-instances, s3 sync, cloudformation |
| Very Complex | 8+h | DynamoDB query, complex state management |
- All 5 Tier 1 services at 80%+ coverage
- Top 20 commands working
- 50% of typical use cases covered
- Performance parity with Python CLI
- 90%+ test coverage for Phase 1
- Replacement for 50%+ of AWS CLI workflows
- Fast startup time (< 1 second)
- Consistent with Python CLI
- Good error messages
- Ready for production use
| Operation | Target | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| CLI startup | < 1 second | Rust advantage over Python |
| S3 list (1000 objects) | < 5 seconds | Network limited |
| S3 copy (100MB file) | 80%+ network efficiency | Limited by network |
| EC2 describe | < 5 seconds | For <10k instances |
| IAM list | < 2 seconds | For <1k users/roles |
| Lambda invoke | < 2 seconds | Cold starts excluded |
- S3 Sync Algorithm → Use tested approach from Python CLI
- Parameter Complexity → Use Clap for validation
- Output Format Match → Thorough testing against Python CLI
- Performance → Async operations, connection pooling
- Credential Chain → Leverage AWS SDK
- Service Coverage → Phase-based approach
- API Changes → Regular SDK updates
- Basic Operations → Well-defined
- Error Handling → AWS SDK provides good types
- Documentation → Extensive examples exist
- Research complete (THIS DOCUMENT)
- Team onboarding
- Setup development environment
- Begin S3 sync implementation
- Target: S3 sync 50% complete
- Complete S3 sync and presign
- Start EC2 run-instances
- Begin IAM user/role CRUD
- Target: S3 & STS at 100%, EC2 at 60%, IAM at 40%
- Complete EC2 security groups
- Complete IAM user/role/policy operations
- Start RDS basic support
- Target: All at 70%+ coverage
- Complete RDS basic support
- Polish all Phase 1 services
- Comprehensive testing
- MVP Release
- Target: All Phase 1 at 80%+ coverage
- Read RESEARCH_EXECUTIVE_SUMMARY.md (30 min)
- Review AWS_CLI_SERVICES_RESEARCH.md Phase 1 (1 hour)
- Study IMPLEMENTATION_CHECKLIST.md (45 min)
- Setup development environment
- Create GitHub issues for Phase 1 items
- Schedule team kickoff meeting
- Begin implementation
| Document | Purpose | Read Time |
|---|---|---|
| RESEARCH_EXECUTIVE_SUMMARY.md | Strategic overview | 30 min |
| AWS_CLI_SERVICES_RESEARCH.md | Detailed service reference | 1-2 hours |
| IMPLEMENTATION_CHECKLIST.md | Execution checklist | 45 min |
| COMMAND_PATTERNS_GUIDE.md | Usage examples | Reference |
| RESEARCH_DOCUMENTATION_INDEX.md | Navigation guide | 15 min |
- Services analyzed: 50+
- Commands analyzed: 300+
- MVP commands: ~100
- Phase 1 (MVP): 4-5 weeks
- Phase 1-2 (Beta): 8-10 weeks
- Phase 1-3 (Stable): 16-20 weeks
- All phases (Complete): 20+ weeks
- MVP: 100-150 hours
- Phase 1-2: 200-250 hours
- Phase 1-3: 350-400 hours
- All: 500+ hours
- MVP: 2-3 developers
- Full: 3-5 developers long-term
- S3 - Add 3 commands (sync, mv, presign)
- EC2 - Add 10 commands (run-instances, terminate, security groups, key pairs)
- IAM - Add 15+ commands (user/role/policy CRUD, attach/detach)
- RDS - Add 10+ commands (full basic support)
- STS - Add 2 commands (assume-role, get-session-token)
Total: ~40 new commands, 100-150 hours
✓ Users can deploy Lambda functions ✓ Users can manage EC2 instances ✓ Users can transfer files with S3 ✓ Users can manage IAM permissions ✓ Users can backup RDS databases ✓ Startup time < 1 second ✓ Performance matches Python CLI ✓ Help text is complete ✓ Errors are helpful ✓ All features work correctly
"What commands do I need to implement?" → AWS_CLI_SERVICES_RESEARCH.md
"How long will it take?" → IMPLEMENTATION_CHECKLIST.md (Effort column)
"What are common patterns?" → COMMAND_PATTERNS_GUIDE.md
"What's the overall strategy?" → RESEARCH_EXECUTIVE_SUMMARY.md
"Where do I find examples?" → COMMAND_PATTERNS_GUIDE.md
"What's our progress?" → IMPLEMENTATION_CHECKLIST.md (Checkboxes)
Research Completed: March 30, 2024 Status: Ready for Implementation Next Step: Begin Phase 1 Development